jim wrote:So who turns out to be the better player, Gibson or Butler? Gibson has really regressed some, personally I think Butler has more raw talent and a better chance to continue the growth.
I think they have similar skill sets in that they are fit, strong, very good man defenders with offensive limitations. Taj is a harder player to find - the athletic, rim protecting big, but Butler's size and speed makes him able to guard three positions and in today's NBA, that kind of versatility against guys that are able to flex from SG to PF like LeBron, Melo, Durant etc, it makes Butler really, really valuable.
Obviously I dont know either of these guys and this is the kind of amateur/voyeuristic psychology I try to avoid as a sports fan, but I think Butler is a more fiery competitor and even though I think it's close, I agree that he's got the bigger upside.
I've had very brief conversations with Sam Smith about both of those players and I recall him saying that both were intelligent and hard working guys ... I think he even classified both as overachievers. I just think that Butler has more upset and might not stall out like I think Taj has done - at least offensively - this year. Taj is still a premium shot blocker/defender, but he isn't bringing as much to the table on O as I had hoped.
btw - one down side of being a Bulls fan is getting jipped watching other teams stars. Went to the Cleveland game with lipp in January and looked forward to seeing Irving - well we saw him but a pretty pedestrian game from him. He didn't really showcase much, because the Bulls defense contained him. Kidd-Gilchrest .. same thing. Kobe the other night etc... The Bulls turn other teams stars into solid players, solid players into Nazr Mohammed. The exception is the Clippers. They looked like the Clippers when we played them.
I've long advocated trying to bring him back before the break if possible, because of the break. It would allow him to get his feet wet and then take a week off to see how things are going. It also doesn't hurt that I am going to the Spurs game on Feb 11.
jim wrote:I've long advocated trying to bring him back before the break if possible, because of the break. It would allow him to get his feet wet and then take a week off to see how things are going. It also doesn't hurt that I am going to the Spurs game on Feb 11.
Where do you see he is a week away?
Thibs and GarPax have always said that taking full contact in practice is the final hurdle. I'm just guessing that it's a week or so.
lukethedrifter wrote:that's only about the money, right?
Not only,but it's a part of it. Gay isn't an efficient player, and Hollinger (the Memphis GM) is an advanced stat nut. He used to work for ESPN, and his trade machine analysis says Toronto is now projected for 6 fewer wins.