RAVE: Mad Men

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31090
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: RAVE: Mad Men

Post by Popeye_Card »

BenNX74205 wrote:I watched all of the first season really close together around August/September on the suggestion of a good friend (and I think I posted in this thread earlier), and I enjoyed it. I caught up to live airings about the time Don spent all episode with the wealthy european bathing suit club or whatever, where he left Wesley Crusher back at the other resort, so I don't know how the second season ended.

And I don't really feel compelled to come back to the show. Looking back on the show, I'm not really sure what it was that pulled me into the show. It's a great period piece, and some of the drama/episodes were good from what I recall (wanted to beat the [expletive] out of Duck when he threw his dog out, but it was a good episode I think).

I'm somewhat torn, because I feel that even if this is exactly what people were like in the 50s/60s, and even if this is an accurate portrayal or the time, I just don't find the characters believable/realistic. It just doesn't resonate with me having separated myself from the series to a degree. Like when Wesley is threatening to out Don, and he asks Ms. Mankin or whoever to run away with him, I just didn't buy that. It didn't seem like the way Don would handle it, and was only there to "raise" the drama of Don doing what you figured he would in the beginning - go to the crazy old Colonel Sanders guy and tell him the truth.

Many of the actors and actresses do a wonderful job, but I dunno man....I just don't feel the need to come back to the show. I feel as if I've gotten all it has to offer. I mean Don has committed adultery with, what, four? five? six? different women over the course of the 20-ish episodes I've seen. A hippie; a client; a married woman; the european young chick.....I'm sure I'm missing at least one, but it's just going to keep going. The only characters I can think of that undergo any development and change are Peggy, who goes through A TON of character development (andseems to be the foil for seemingly everyone else in the show in that regard, and they're very heavyhanded in the way they do it: "hey so-and-so got so drunk he passed out and pissed his pants, let's let good ol' Peggy give the presentation!" and then "oh wow I didn't know a girl could do that let's let her do more for us!") and Roger (whoever plays the Larry Tate to Don's Darin from "Bewitched"), and all he did was leave his wife to be with the hot young thing - not really much "development" there.

Sorry to rain on the parade here, but I did enjoy the show when I started watching it, but I just haven't felt compelled to keep following things. Am I just misremembering (it has been a few months since I've watched any of it)?
You must hold TV shows up to some pretty high standards. One can find faults in anything if you look for them.

It's an excellent show in my opinion, and I'm eagerly anticipating the next season.

BenNX74205
All-Star
Posts: 2541
Joined: April 18 06, 2:57 pm

Re: RAVE: Mad Men

Post by BenNX74205 »

Popeye_Card wrote:You must hold TV shows up to some pretty high standards. One can find faults in anything if you look for them.

It's an excellent show in my opinion, and I'm eagerly anticipating the next season.
I'd like to think I have high standards, but I did stick with the new Knight Rider for more than one episode, so nobody's perfect.

It's true you can find faults with anything, and I find faults with even my all-time favorite tv shows.

I guess I feel that the actors do a great job of playing their roles, and they nail the period perfectly, but I just feel like the characters by and large don't really change as the series has progressed. Don is still committing adultery and ignoring his family; Wesley is still in the same bad marriage and secretly pining for Peggy; Sal is still in the closet (as far as I know - haven't seen the whole second season). And the characters that do develop, again, just seem to develop in a heavyhanded manner. From the first to the second season, the larger alcoholic guy grows a beard, moves to the village, becomes a playwright, starts dating an African American woman, and starts fighting for civil rights. I know the show jumped like two years into the future or something between seasons, but it just feels so drastic.

I don't get the same feeling of inter-episode cohesion that I get from other serialized dramas. The connections by and large are relegated to the B- or C- or even D-plots for the episodes (the Nixon campaign; Betty and the Mini-Me Don; etc), while the weekly A-plot jumps around from week to week. Or maybe there just isn't an A-plot driving each episode? I'm not sure. Sometimes there is and sometimes there isn't, at least from what I can recall. I guess I feel it's a character study without enough of a driving narrative to it for my taste. As I said, I enjoyed what I've seen, but I don't feel like I'm missing anything by no longer watching. I found the characters interesting, but they didn't seem to be moving towards anything particular as a collective.

Again I'm probably coming off as overly critical because there is a lot that I like/liked about the series; it's just that the plot/story isn't pulling me into watching any more. January Jones is by far the best thing about the show, and I'm not even talking about her looks. Her performance is amazing every week, and the rest of the cast is very strong as well. But in a world of limited television viewing hours, I can only watch so many shows, and there are just more shows that I enjoy watching more.

Maybe when "new tv" settles down and I have less "new tv" to watch I'll finish off the season. I'm just not gripped enough by the storylines to feel compelled to watch the series as it airs.

User avatar
thrill
bronoun enthusiast
Posts: 30539
Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
Location: barely online

Re: RAVE: Mad Men

Post by thrill »

Honestly, 60% of why I love the show is the style and mood, not necessarily it's plots.

Jocephus
99% conan clips
Posts: 64992
Joined: April 18 06, 5:14 pm

Re: RAVE: Mad Men

Post by Jocephus »

thrill wrote:Honestly, 60% of why I love the show is the style and mood, not necessarily it's plots.
same (im enjoying the plots so far too, but ive only watched the first four episodes)

User avatar
JL21
NPR & THT Contributor
Posts: 36109
Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
Location: Chocolate City

Re: RAVE: Mad Men

Post by JL21 »

I enjoy it, but not as much as most people do. The soap opera-ish plot lines drive me crazy. "Ooooh, Peggy is pregnant", "Don has a double super-secret past life", "Betty is bored and Don is cheating on her with everything that moves", "Pete Campbell can't conceive with his wife and is butting heads with his in-laws", "Everybody knows that Peggy had a kid!", etc...

I keep waiting for Don to end up in a coma, only to wake up and discover that *gasp* ROGER STERLING IS HIS REAL FATHER! (cue dramatic organ music)

What keeps me watching is the client meetings, and the cool late 50's/early 60's atmosphere. The client meetings are hilarious.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: RAVE: Mad Men

Post by Freed Roger »

JL21 wrote:I enjoy it, but not as much as most people do. The soap opera-ish plot lines drive me crazy. "Ooooh, Peggy is pregnant", "Don has a double super-secret past life", "Betty is bored and Don is cheating on her with everything that moves", "Pete Campbell can't conceive with his wife and is butting heads with his in-laws", "Everybody knows that Peggy had a kid!", etc...

I keep waiting for Don to end up in a coma, only to wake up and discover that *gasp* ROGER STERLING IS HIS REAL FATHER! (cue dramatic organ music)

What keeps me watching is the client meetings, and the cool late 50's/early 60's atmosphere. The client meetings are hilarious.
Yep to this.

There was good character development and storylines at the beginning, but devolved into full-fledged soap opera. but as a period piece, its great to watch. and that redhead. zow!

BenNX74205
All-Star
Posts: 2541
Joined: April 18 06, 2:57 pm

Re: RAVE: Mad Men

Post by BenNX74205 »

JL21 wrote:I enjoy it, but not as much as most people do. The soap opera-ish plot lines drive me crazy. "Ooooh, Peggy is pregnant", "Don has a double super-secret past life", "Betty is bored and Don is cheating on her with everything that moves", "Pete Campbell can't conceive with his wife and is butting heads with his in-laws", "Everybody knows that Peggy had a kid!", etc...

I keep waiting for Don to end up in a coma, only to wake up and discover that *gasp* ROGER STERLING IS HIS REAL FATHER! (cue dramatic organ music)

What keeps me watching is the client meetings, and the cool late 50's/early 60's atmosphere. The client meetings are hilarious.
I agree with this 110%. There are great things going on within each episode. And they nail the period to a T (from what I can tell/know). I guess I just wanted to express that those things are great, but taken as a whole it wasn't enough to pull me back week after week. I am content to wait before continuing to watch the show. That's mostly what I wanted to express, but I easily go off on tangents when posting. I only have a few shows that I love (enjoy?) enough to stay current with their broadcast schedule (i.e. watch my DVR-d episode before it records the next new one; there's only one show I don't watch "time-shifted"), and my tv viewing time is much more limited with working/commuting ~60 hrs/week.
Freed Roger wrote:and that redhead. zow!
Yeah, she's great. You can also find her as Saffron on "Firefly" and Olivia on "Life." Definitely easy on the eyes.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31090
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: RAVE: Mad Men

Post by Popeye_Card »

BenNX74205 wrote:
Popeye_Card wrote:You must hold TV shows up to some pretty high standards. One can find faults in anything if you look for them.

It's an excellent show in my opinion, and I'm eagerly anticipating the next season.
I'd like to think I have high standards, but I did stick with the new Knight Rider for more than one episode, so nobody's perfect.

It's true you can find faults with anything, and I find faults with even my all-time favorite tv shows.

I guess I feel that the actors do a great job of playing their roles, and they nail the period perfectly, but I just feel like the characters by and large don't really change as the series has progressed. Don is still committing adultery and ignoring his family; Wesley is still in the same bad marriage and secretly pining for Peggy; Sal is still in the closet (as far as I know - haven't seen the whole second season). And the characters that do develop, again, just seem to develop in a heavyhanded manner. From the first to the second season, the larger alcoholic guy grows a beard, moves to the village, becomes a playwright, starts dating an African American woman, and starts fighting for civil rights. I know the show jumped like two years into the future or something between seasons, but it just feels so drastic.

I don't get the same feeling of inter-episode cohesion that I get from other serialized dramas. The connections by and large are relegated to the B- or C- or even D-plots for the episodes (the Nixon campaign; Betty and the Mini-Me Don; etc), while the weekly A-plot jumps around from week to week. Or maybe there just isn't an A-plot driving each episode? I'm not sure. Sometimes there is and sometimes there isn't, at least from what I can recall. I guess I feel it's a character study without enough of a driving narrative to it for my taste. As I said, I enjoyed what I've seen, but I don't feel like I'm missing anything by no longer watching. I found the characters interesting, but they didn't seem to be moving towards anything particular as a collective.

Again I'm probably coming off as overly critical because there is a lot that I like/liked about the series; it's just that the plot/story isn't pulling me into watching any more. January Jones is by far the best thing about the show, and I'm not even talking about her looks. Her performance is amazing every week, and the rest of the cast is very strong as well. But in a world of limited television viewing hours, I can only watch so many shows, and there are just more shows that I enjoy watching more.

Maybe when "new tv" settles down and I have less "new tv" to watch I'll finish off the season. I'm just not gripped enough by the storylines to feel compelled to watch the series as it airs.
It's incredibly Sopranos-esque. Don and Tony are nearly identical. Many of the side characters are supposed to be just that--characters--and do they necessarily need to go through huge developments? Like most shows, they're side dressing to make things interesting once in a while. Honestly, I can't think of any other TV shows right now that do much more than Mad Men in the areas you're criticizing on. Plot twists are often corny and predictable. Character developement--when it does happen--is usually predictable and overdone as well.

What I like about the characters in Mad Men is similar to what I liked about the characters in Sopranos. They know their faults. They stick out like a sore thumb at times. But when they show them, they do what's instinctively human--go back to the faulty person you were, often to the extreme. Too tough to change. Don't want to embarrass yourself by doing so. The only guy that seems completely comfortable in his own skin is Cosgrove.

Jocephus
99% conan clips
Posts: 64992
Joined: April 18 06, 5:14 pm

Re: RAVE: Mad Men

Post by Jocephus »

i also love the intro and song

maddash
is eerily well-versed on Project Runway and irony
Posts: 8508
Joined: June 26 06, 3:07 pm

Re: RAVE: Mad Men

Post by maddash »

Mad Men deals in metaphor more than most shows. I think you have to view it on that level. While the characters and their development are still important, you kind of have to back up to see the forest for the trees - as it's dealing with these grandiose themes of human nature, as much as it is the nuances of character interaction.

Post Reply