Hungary Jack wrote: MSU is a fine team, but they were moments away from losing to Notre Dame and Northwestern. I have a hard time putting them in the same echelon as Bama, Mizzou, and Auburn.
No offense to Missouri (because I think they're really good), but didn't Missouri need somewhat of a "miracle" to beat San Diego State at home? Now, San Diego State isn't a horrible team, but I don't think that Notre Dame and Northwestern are either. And let's remember that Missouri has only played 1 road game all year. I don't think that Missouri has proven themselves any more worthy than Michigan State has.
Missouri just beat Oklahoma, and fairly convincingly. Sparty's best win is over Wisconsin.
OU is #9 in the BCS. Wisconsin is #10.
Missouri beat OU by 9 points. Michigan State beat Wisconsin by 10 points.
Missouri really hasn't done anything that's more impressive than Michigan State has, to this point.
This week, Missour plays at #14 Nebraska, while Michigan State plays at #18 Iowa.
Socnorb11 wrote:
But not more than Missouri? That's a bias, in my opinion.
Michigan State will have beaten every team on their schedule, just like Missouri. Neither of them will have played more than 2 teams that are currently ranked. I don't see how this is a no-brainer, but we can agree to disagree.
How is that bias? Mizzou will play OU twice if they go undefeated. Plus follow up beating OU by playing Nebraska in Lincoln. OU>just about anyone in the BigX. Yes, Michigan State will be penalized for not playing a conf. championship.....imagine that, not facing as many good teams hurts you which is I believe why the Big X is adding a team so they can play one. This is turning into one of those annoying conversations where you can't prove what you're saying so you're just going to end up asking the same question over and over in different way which is stupid.
Again, if MO beats OU (who imo is just as good as anyone in the BigX) then yes they should be considered in a different class than MI State.
Aren't we both saying the same things repeatedly? And neither one of us are proving anything. There is no proof. But at least most of us are having a civil discussion about it.
Socnorb11 wrote:OU is #9 in the BCS. Wisconsin is #10.
Missouri beat OU by 9 points. Michigan State beat Wisconsin by 10 points.
Missouri really hasn't done anything that's more impressive than Michigan State has, to this point.
This week, Missour plays at #14 Nebraska, while Michigan State plays at #18 Iowa.
Michigan State faced Northwestern last week while Mizzou faced OU. This week they will face similarly talented teams. If you think the prior week doesn't factor in at all, then I don't know what to say.
Socnorb11 wrote:OU is #9 in the BCS. Wisconsin is #10.
Missouri beat OU by 9 points. Michigan State beat Wisconsin by 10 points.
Missouri really hasn't done anything that's more impressive than Michigan State has, to this point.
This week, Missour plays at #14 Nebraska, while Michigan State plays at #18 Iowa.
Michigan State faced Northwestern last week while Mizzou faced OU. This week they will face similarly talented teams. If you think the prior week doesn't factor in at all, then I don't know what to say.
That has absolutely nothing to do with this particular discussion, unless you think that what happened last week proves that the Big XII is a better conference than the Big 10. If that's your point, then I also don't know what to say.
Socnorb11 wrote:
Aren't we both saying the same things repeatedly? And neither one of us are proving anything. There is no proof. But at least most of us are having a civil discussion about it.
Exactly, and that's what's annoying. You just keep questioning my points. You're right in that I am going to continue to defend the SEC West as the best division and the winner as the best team and Mizzou above Michigan State. The SEC West winner will play roughly 6 ranked teams throughout the year. The Big X winner (assuming it's Mi State will play 2). IF it's Iowa, then they'll have what 4? And, one loss. Crazy how the more difficult your schedule is the more losses you end up with.
Regardless, until you post an opinion, it's tough to have a conversation. The last post you made, the only opinion you had was that I was biased. Yet, never did you claim Michigan State was better than Mizzou only pointed out (incorrectly) that they would play the same number of ranked teams and didn't account for Mizzou playing OU twice or the fact that OU is just as good as if not better than anyone in the Big X.
Socnorb11 wrote:
Aren't we both saying the same things repeatedly? And neither one of us are proving anything. There is no proof. But at least most of us are having a civil discussion about it.
Exactly, and that's what's annoying. You just keep questioning my points. You're right in that I am going to continue to defend the SEC West as the best division and the winner as the best team and Mizzou above Michigan State. The SEC West winner will play roughly 6 ranked teams throughout the year. The Big X winner (assuming it's Mi State will play 2). IF it's Iowa, then they'll have what 4? And, one loss. Crazy how the more difficult your schedule is the more losses you end up with.
Regardless, until you post an opinion, it's tough to have a conversation. The last post you made, the only opinion you had was that I was biased. Yet, never did you claim Michigan State was better than Mizzou only pointed out (incorrectly) that they would play the same number of ranked teams and didn't account for Mizzou playing OU twice or the fact that OU is just as good as if not better than anyone in the Big X.
Mizzou may not play OU twice, though. Right now, Baylor leads the South.
Socnorb11 wrote:
That has absolutely nothing to do with this particular discussion, unless you think that what happened last week proves that the Big XII is a better conference than the Big 10. If that's your point, then I also don't know what to say.
Imo, that's flat out wrong. In college especially, trap games do exist and having to get up for 2-3 top 25 teams in a row is much more difficult than getting to spread them out over the course of a season. And, it's likely the reason Mizzou is a 7 point dog despite being just as talented as Nebraska.
Socnorb11 wrote:
Aren't we both saying the same things repeatedly? And neither one of us are proving anything. There is no proof. But at least most of us are having a civil discussion about it.
Exactly, and that's what's annoying. You just keep questioning my points. You're right in that I am going to continue to defend the SEC West as the best division and the winner as the best team and Mizzou above Michigan State. The SEC West winner will play roughly 6 ranked teams throughout the year. The Big X winner (assuming it's Mi State will play 2). IF it's Iowa, then they'll have what 4? And, one loss. Crazy how the more difficult your schedule is the more losses you end up with.
Regardless, until you post an opinion, it's tough to have a conversation. The last post you made, the only opinion you had was that I was biased. Yet, never did you claim Michigan State was better than Mizzou only pointed out (incorrectly) that they would play the same number of ranked teams and didn't account for Mizzou playing OU twice or the fact that OU is just as good as if not better than anyone in the Big X.
I don't see what playing OU twice is going to prove. Missouri is better than OU. I think they have proven that pretty conclusively. Michigan State is better than Wisconsin (the 2nd best team in the conference). Again, they have proven that conclusively.
My opinion is that Missouri isn't really proving anything that Michigan State isn't proving. That obviously may change, and you are obviously entitled to have a different opinion. About all we can do is compare head-to-head games between the Big Ten and the Big XII. There aren't many. Illinois (mid-tier team in the Big 10) was right with Missoui until late in the 4th quarter, in a game that was essentially a home game for Missouri. Are there any other Big 10 vs. Big XII matchups that we can look at? I honestly don't know.
Socnorb11 wrote:
Aren't we both saying the same things repeatedly? And neither one of us are proving anything. There is no proof. But at least most of us are having a civil discussion about it.
Exactly, and that's what's annoying. You just keep questioning my points. You're right in that I am going to continue to defend the SEC West as the best division and the winner as the best team and Mizzou above Michigan State. The SEC West winner will play roughly 6 ranked teams throughout the year. The Big X winner (assuming it's Mi State will play 2). IF it's Iowa, then they'll have what 4? And, one loss. Crazy how the more difficult your schedule is the more losses you end up with.
Regardless, until you post an opinion, it's tough to have a conversation. The last post you made, the only opinion you had was that I was biased. Yet, never did you claim Michigan State was better than Mizzou only pointed out (incorrectly) that they would play the same number of ranked teams and didn't account for Mizzou playing OU twice or the fact that OU is just as good as if not better than anyone in the Big X.
Mizzou may not play OU twice, though. Right now, Baylor leads the South.
Suffice it to say, the winner of the South will be ranked.
And Mizzou may not win the North. Still a lot of if's out there right now.
I don't think the Big 12 will end up with an undefeated team--just my hunch. Ditto for the SEC. If Michigan State wins this weekend, they have a clear shot to the finish line. So that leaves a scenario in my mind of choosing between 4 undefeateds for 2 spots--Oregon, Michigan State, Boise State, and TCU. If Oregon gets to that point, they're a no-brainer in a very tough Pac 10. Michigan State, by avoiding Ohio State, is a bit tougher call if they are any better than Boise or TCU, who I want to see eventually get a shot.
Bottom line though, if Mizzou is the best team in the Big XII and Michigan State is the best team in the Big 10, I don't know that either conference is overly good. Maybe it is just a down year in college football.