Point of fact: The 911 operator never instructed him to NOT confront Trayvon. She kept saying "You don't have to do that," which could actually be perceived as permissive. In fact, had Trayvon been an actual burglar, the stand your ground law works, regardless of the operator's instructions.vinsanity wrote:Zimmerman charged with second degree murder and manslaughter.Cole Burns wrote:Let's see...same state that let Casey Anthony go free? There's no way that could happen twice.
This is an easy prophecy: Buildings will burn.
I'm not sure this case is the same as the Casey Anthony trial at all. The prosecution went for first degree and manslaughter there as well, but their case was much more unsure. They had to prove she intended to kill her child for the murder charge or that it was gross negligence that led to her death. Is it not reasonable to believe the child died in a tragic, unpreventable circumstance?
Here you have a guy who has admitted he shot the victim. You have a guy who called 911 thinking someone was suspicious. An operator repeatedly asking the man to not confront the victim and confronted him anyway. You have a man who has an alleged history of violence. When you instigate a confrontation, with a loaded weapon no less, I think you have a hard time justifying that deadly force was necessary. Both men would have their lives if Zimmerman had stayed away, as the operator asked him to do.
But, we don't have all the evidence either. We shall see.
The truth of all of this lies somewhere in between the two leaked accounts of the incident. I don't entirely believe Zimmerman, but I also don't entirely believe Trayvon's girlfriend. What I think happened was Zimmerman saw who he thought was a burglar, decided to confront him since the police would likely arrive too late. Upon confronting Trayvon a scuffle ensued (instigated by whom, we'll never truly know - Zimmerman because he followed him? Or Trayvon because of a perceived threat). The ensuing confrontation led Zimmerman, still under the impression that Trayvon was a burglar, to engage with a handgun. Now, here's where the mystery lies and here's where it gets real fuzzy...I think that what happened was an accidental shooting. Zimmerman had the safety off, there's a scuffle and Trayvon doesn't see the gun, and the gun fires and hits Trayvon. Of course many would disagree with that.
I also don't think that Zimmerman was a racist - garbled audio on 911 tape to the contrary - but was looking for anyone who fit the physical/attired description of a burglar. Race plaid a part in this only after the fact, really, and is more about the police's lack of response to the situation.
In the end, I think manslaughter would be easier to prosecute (which made me wonder why they're going murder 2 - can they go lower in Florida once the trial starts?), and would actually lead to a plea deal on this one.
Ultimately, I don't think the prosecution can prove murder 2 - see, OJ - and I think he'll walk.



