Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
- stlouie_lipp
- Hallelujah Brother
- Posts: 13380
- Joined: April 17 06, 7:36 pm
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
The release of "Smells Like Teen Spirit" put the nail in the coffin for hair bands. For that alone Nirvana deserves a high ranking.
Online
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30873
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
I give GNR credit for this too, and Metallica to a lesser extent. GNR had the look of a hair band at first, but musically not even close. And they pretty quickly went to a grungier look even before "grunge" became fashionable.stlouie_lipp wrote:The release of "Smells Like Teen Spirit" put the nail in the coffin for hair bands. For that alone Nirvana deserves a high ranking.
- JackofDiamonds
- Bringer of Boston Baked Blue Balls
- Posts: 15010
- Joined: April 16 06, 9:15 pm
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
InvincibleCakeEater wrote:I agree for the most part and would say 100% of hair metal guitarists could wipe the floor with Cobain. I'm no musical prodigy, but was playing every single note of Nirvana songs at 12. It's just easy.Popeye_Card wrote:The guitarist thing just bugs me because there was absolutely nothing special about his guitar playing technically, nor were any of the riffs anything iconic. Their reasoning was basically the same as all the justification for Nirvana praise--HE ENDED THE BUTT ROCK!--but hell, 90% of hair bad guitarists wipe the floor with Cobain. You're honestly going to tell me that he's a "greater" guitarist than Slash? There is no way on earth you can justify that. None.
The undisputed greatest guitar player of all time once said, "Heaven is lying at Buddy Guy's feet while listening to him play guitar.". That gets you a 30th rank. Being at the right place at the right time to end butt rock gets you 12th. The list is thus freaking worthless.
And you must be confused, that's Jimi's quote, not Jeff Beck's. /I'm dumb and wrong.
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31097
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
I think in any discussion of Nirvana, hair bands are given way too much credit for their supposed domination of rock. GnR was probably the biggest rock band at the onset of Nirvana, and they weren't really a hair band. Warrant, Poison, et al? Popular, sure. But that style of rock had only been the dominant form for a few years. And it isn't like the 90's was just chock full of awesome rock. A few alternative bands are legit legends. The rest, not much better than the forgetable hair bands. The legacy of the 80's wasn't hair bands as much as it was Michael Jackson and pop. The legacy of the 90's, IMO, isn't alternative rock as much as it was the explosion of hip hop.
-
TimeForGuinness
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 20007
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:38 pm
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
I'd attribute the rise of Hip Hop/Rap in the 90's to killing hair rock more than Nirvana...but I guess if you needed an heir to the rock throne, Nirvana would be the one for that period.
- InvincibleCakeEater
- GRB's obsessive compulsive baseball poster
- Posts: 28275
- Joined: October 12 07, 12:28 pm
- Location: Raptured
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
Y-your head has the sh- sh..shell on it.JackofDiamonds wrote:InvincibleCakeEater wrote:I agree for the most part and would say 100% of hair metal guitarists could wipe the floor with Cobain. I'm no musical prodigy, but was playing every single note of Nirvana songs at 12. It's just easy.Popeye_Card wrote:The guitarist thing just bugs me because there was absolutely nothing special about his guitar playing technically, nor were any of the riffs anything iconic. Their reasoning was basically the same as all the justification for Nirvana praise--HE ENDED THE BUTT ROCK!--but hell, 90% of hair bad guitarists wipe the floor with Cobain. You're honestly going to tell me that he's a "greater" guitarist than Slash? There is no way on earth you can justify that. None.
The undisputed greatest guitar player of all time once said, "Heaven is lying at Buddy Guy's feet while listening to him play guitar.". That gets you a 30th rank. Being at the right place at the right time to end butt rock gets you 12th. The list is thus freaking worthless.
And you must be confused, that's Jimi's quote, not Jeff Beck's. /I'm dumb and wrong.
- heyzeus
- Everday Unicorn
- Posts: 43336
- Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
- Location: Austin, TX
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
Nirvana wasn't just at the right place and time, they made the right place and time happen.
Nevermind wasn't a brand new form of music; other seattle bands had been doing the same thing for a few years and it wasn't even Nirvana's first album. Kurt Cobain himself said Smells Like Teen Spirit was a Pixies ripoff.
No, Nirvana was a combination of all of the right things at the right time. Michael Jackson was starting to wear thin, and pop junk like C+C Music Factory was the norm. Nirvana had the look (c'mon, teenage girls didn't all buy Kurt tshirts and posters just because of his singing), a new sound that was dark and edgy, and an insanely catchy first single. An anthemic video (back when videos mattered).
And that might be the biggest element of all. Smells Like Teen Spirit is the perfect rock single. The intro guitar riff is now a hallmark of rock - instantly recognizable from the second you hear it. So simple, you wonder how nobody had put it together before.
Nevermind wasn't a brand new form of music; other seattle bands had been doing the same thing for a few years and it wasn't even Nirvana's first album. Kurt Cobain himself said Smells Like Teen Spirit was a Pixies ripoff.
No, Nirvana was a combination of all of the right things at the right time. Michael Jackson was starting to wear thin, and pop junk like C+C Music Factory was the norm. Nirvana had the look (c'mon, teenage girls didn't all buy Kurt tshirts and posters just because of his singing), a new sound that was dark and edgy, and an insanely catchy first single. An anthemic video (back when videos mattered).
And that might be the biggest element of all. Smells Like Teen Spirit is the perfect rock single. The intro guitar riff is now a hallmark of rock - instantly recognizable from the second you hear it. So simple, you wonder how nobody had put it together before.
- stlouie_lipp
- Hallelujah Brother
- Posts: 13380
- Joined: April 17 06, 7:36 pm
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
Good post.heyzeus wrote:Nirvana wasn't just at the right place and time, they made the right place and time happen.
Nevermind wasn't a brand new form of music; other seattle bands had been doing the same thing for a few years and it wasn't even Nirvana's first album. Kurt Cobain himself said Smells Like Teen Spirit was a Pixies ripoff.
No, Nirvana was a combination of all of the right things at the right time. Michael Jackson was starting to wear thin, and pop junk like C+C Music Factory was the norm. Nirvana had the look (c'mon, teenage girls didn't all buy Kurt tshirts and posters just because of his singing), a new sound that was dark and edgy, and an insanely catchy first single. An anthemic video (back when videos mattered).
And that might be the biggest element of all. Smells Like Teen Spirit is the perfect rock single. The intro guitar riff is now a hallmark of rock - instantly recognizable from the second you hear it. So simple, you wonder how nobody had put it together before.
- The Third Man
- It rubs the lotion on its skin.
- Posts: 8935
- Joined: July 17 06, 1:00 pm
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
That best guitarists list just sucks all around. Mick Taylor didn't even make the cut. Eddie Van Halen is down in the seventies somewhere.
- Tambourine Man
- accepts no jimitators
- Posts: 11413
- Joined: April 21 06, 3:31 pm
- Location: I Read the News Today Oh, boy
Re: Rolling Stone Magazine and Nirvana
/insert snarky commentThe Third Man wrote:Mick Taylor didn't even make the cut.





