GatewayRedbirds.com

I love this move..It's going to be interesting to see who is off the rotation..Gotta be Ponson/Suppan..Maybe Marquis?

Reyes deserves to be here no doubt.

Carpenter
Reyes
Mulder
Weaver
Marquis/Wainwright


...Who knows?!

Michael wrote:

fanforever wrote:Carpenter, Mulder, Reyes, and Weaver for the Playoffs?

Maybe in 81 games it'll be clicking?

[-o<

I believe in Dave Duncan. Woody Williams, Kile, Stewart, Welch.

Slick avatar STLBirds23.

Michael wrote:

longhornbaseball wrote:

Michael wrote:The big question is who's out? It's gotta be Ponson.

If its Reyes, I quit.

I refuse to believe that would happpen.

Again, assuming is gone Ponson what happens when Mulder comes back?

I don't want to think about it either, but those HRs that Reyes gave up did come off the high fastball (IIRC). The very same high fastball that TLR asked Reyes to work on getting away from down in the minors....

Just throwing it out there as a possibility - maybe a 5% chance at this point.

If Marquis can string together a few more "good" starts, I have the feeling he'll be traded for a LF bat.

I've always disliked him but now I have to like him.

I always thought he was overrated.

But now our pitchers are terrible.

so...GO WEAVER!!!!

:roll:

So, what are we looking at here???

ITEM: Weaver is not, and never has been, a ground-ball oriented pitcher. It will be particularly interesting to see how our outfield "defense" affects him.

ITEM: Weaver has been pretty bad across the board this year, but the biggest reason for his results: he's allowed 18 homers in less than 90 IP. I have not seen him pitch mutch this year, so I'm not sure if there is a fluke component to that, or if he has simply really been that hittable.

ITEM: Weaver has given up a BABIP of .338 this year, and he has managed to strand only 62% of his runners. Both of those things suggest a significant degree of bad luck. In that regard, sight-unseen he appears to be a legit candidate for a turnaround even if he keeps throwing about the same now as he has been all year. Moreso if he actually pitches better too.

ITEM: Lots of people attribute the derailing of a promising career to character, attitude, tough NY fans, etc. I attribute it to --

Nah. You don't really want to know.

Do you?

No, I really don't think you do.

Are you sure? No, let me protect you from yourself. Go. Go now.

Are you still here? Ok then, suit yourself:

Age 21: 163 major league innings
Age 22: 200 major league innings, ERA+ of 111
Age 23: 229 major league innings, and 110 pitcher PER START (ERA+ of 109)
Age 24: 199 major league innings, 112 pitches per start; ERA+ of 121
Age 25 on: ERA+ of 73, 103, 96, and this year's 50something.

I've always disliked him but now I have to like him.

Definitly disliked him.

I always thought he was overrated.

Definitely overrated.

But now our pitchers are terrible.

so...GO WEAVER!!!!

GO WEAVER!

Age 20: 163 major league innings
Age 21: 200 major league innings, ERA+ of 111
Age 22: 229 major league innings, and 110 pitcher PER START (ERA+ of 109)
Age 23: 199 major league innings, 112 pitches per start; ERA+ of 121
Age 24: 5.99 ERA

Hilarious.

You can always find a way to throw that into almost every discussion. And we still have no way to prove you right. Or wrong.

I think its a worthwhile move. Didn't give up much. The guy has to be dying for a turnaround. He just got booted to make room for his little brother. That would be a huge motivator for me, just sheer pride

fanforever wrote:Again I wish to point out it's amazing how people can make mediocrity smell good

Who's doing that? What are you refering to? We are taking a flyer on a guy who's has some success in the past for next to nothing.