Rave: High School Football
- GeddyWrox
- Caught you a delicious bass
- Posts: 14726
- Joined: April 20 06, 8:43 pm
- Location: Please use blue font for the sarcasm impaired.
Re: Rave: High School Football
Webster won! 
- TGantz
- R-E-S-P-E-C-T...What Dr Pepper Means to Me
- Posts: 6698
- Joined: July 27 06, 11:59 pm
- Location: The Lou
Re: Rave: High School Football
I went to De Smet Jesuit High School, so I guess it's up to me to give an inside point of view.
Is there recruiting going on in private schools, especially with inner-city black kids? Sure. But they aren't getting it handed to them as someone implied earlier. I know for a fact that those guys work their asses off, probably twice as hard as a regular students their age. They constantly come early and then stay late at school because they have to maintain very good grades, do "financial aid" jobs like helping teachers clean up classrooms after school, and work out to keep their bodies in peak shape.
They have talent, and going to a private school gives them a chance to make something of their life. What are they going to do with their lives coming from crappy inner city schools giving them a horrible education? Their sports programs aren't good enough to give them a chance to be seen. I saw Charlie Weis repeatedly at De Smet, as well as Gary Pinkel. Do you think they go downtown to recruit too?
Private schools aren't what you all assume. The comment about half of the students not being Catholic is downright wrong. There were VERY few students that weren't Catholic at De Smet (maybe 15 out of 1,200). Most of the kids that weren't were actually white and another form of Christian faith. Same was true of SLUH, CBC, and Vianney.
I've gone to private schools my entire life. I'm the fifth of seven kids, and we have all gone to private schools our entire lives. My parents aren't rich, and we struggled with payments for school. It was just something that we valued. My parents worked their asses off to be able to send us there. My mom is an elementary school teacher at a Catholic grade school. My Dad has a decent job working as a software engineer. They don't make a ton of money. We made sacrifices.
Don't go knocking people's life choices and values because you're pissed off that a local high school football team loses.
Is there recruiting going on in private schools, especially with inner-city black kids? Sure. But they aren't getting it handed to them as someone implied earlier. I know for a fact that those guys work their asses off, probably twice as hard as a regular students their age. They constantly come early and then stay late at school because they have to maintain very good grades, do "financial aid" jobs like helping teachers clean up classrooms after school, and work out to keep their bodies in peak shape.
They have talent, and going to a private school gives them a chance to make something of their life. What are they going to do with their lives coming from crappy inner city schools giving them a horrible education? Their sports programs aren't good enough to give them a chance to be seen. I saw Charlie Weis repeatedly at De Smet, as well as Gary Pinkel. Do you think they go downtown to recruit too?
Private schools aren't what you all assume. The comment about half of the students not being Catholic is downright wrong. There were VERY few students that weren't Catholic at De Smet (maybe 15 out of 1,200). Most of the kids that weren't were actually white and another form of Christian faith. Same was true of SLUH, CBC, and Vianney.
I've gone to private schools my entire life. I'm the fifth of seven kids, and we have all gone to private schools our entire lives. My parents aren't rich, and we struggled with payments for school. It was just something that we valued. My parents worked their asses off to be able to send us there. My mom is an elementary school teacher at a Catholic grade school. My Dad has a decent job working as a software engineer. They don't make a ton of money. We made sacrifices.
Don't go knocking people's life choices and values because you're pissed off that a local high school football team loses.
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: Rave: High School Football
The alma mater of Hungary Jack, pujolswrox, lukethedrifter and maybe new pagodi (I know there is at least one more WG alum here) won the Class 5 Mo State Football Championship.
- Radbird
- There's someone in my head but it's not me
- Posts: 62390
- Joined: April 18 06, 5:08 pm
- Location: LF Bleachers @ Busch II
Re: Rave: High School Football
WGHS Class of 1971 here.lukethedrifter wrote:The alma mater of Hungary Jack, pujolswrox, lukethedrifter and maybe new pagodi (I know there is at least one more WG alum here) won the Class 5 Mo State Football Championship.
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: Rave: High School Football
Radbird wrote:WGHS Class of 1971 here.lukethedrifter wrote:The alma mater of Hungary Jack, pujolswrox, lukethedrifter and maybe new pagodi (I know there is at least one more WG alum here) won the Class 5 Mo State Football Championship.
Dammit. I knew that. Sorry.
In my mind you were a given and there's one more who I was trying to recall.
-
M1IRONMIKE
- Well hello, pilgrim
- Posts: 4129
- Joined: October 7 06, 7:23 am
- Location: springfield illinois
Re: Rave: High School Football
Once again I do not blame any family for accepting these advantages. I am merely stating that these schools should not be competing against schools that aren't allowed to recruit.Gantz57 wrote:I went to De Smet Jesuit High School, so I guess it's up to me to give an inside point of view.
Is there recruiting going on in private schools, especially with inner-city black kids? Sure. But they aren't getting it handed to them as someone implied earlier. I know for a fact that those guys work their asses off, probably twice as hard as a regular students their age. They constantly come early and then stay late at school because they have to maintain very good grades, do "financial aid" jobs like helping teachers clean up classrooms after school, and work out to keep their bodies in peak shape.
They have talent, and going to a private school gives them a chance to make something of their life. What are they going to do with their lives coming from crappy inner city schools giving them a horrible education? Their sports programs aren't good enough to give them a chance to be seen. I saw Charlie Weis repeatedly at De Smet, as well as Gary Pinkel. Do you think they go downtown to recruit too?
Private schools aren't what you all assume. The comment about half of the students not being Catholic is downright wrong. There were VERY few students that weren't Catholic at De Smet (maybe 15 out of 1,200). Most of the kids that weren't were actually white and another form of Christian faith. Same was true of SLUH, CBC, and Vianney.
I've gone to private schools my entire life. I'm the fifth of seven kids, and we have all gone to private schools our entire lives. My parents aren't rich, and we struggled with payments for school. It was just something that we valued. My parents worked their asses off to be able to send us there. My mom is an elementary school teacher at a Catholic grade school. My Dad has a decent job working as a software engineer. They don't make a ton of money. We made sacrifices.
Don't go knocking people's life choices and values because you're pissed off that a local high school football team loses.
- obucard
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 8181
- Joined: April 18 06, 11:04 pm
- Location: Central AR
Re: Rave: High School Football
M1IRONMIKE wrote:Once again I do not blame any family for accepting these advantages. I am merely stating that these schools should not be competing against schools that aren't allowed to recruit.Gantz57 wrote:I went to De Smet Jesuit High School, so I guess it's up to me to give an inside point of view.
Is there recruiting going on in private schools, especially with inner-city black kids? Sure. But they aren't getting it handed to them as someone implied earlier. I know for a fact that those guys work their asses off, probably twice as hard as a regular students their age. They constantly come early and then stay late at school because they have to maintain very good grades, do "financial aid" jobs like helping teachers clean up classrooms after school, and work out to keep their bodies in peak shape.
They have talent, and going to a private school gives them a chance to make something of their life. What are they going to do with their lives coming from crappy inner city schools giving them a horrible education? Their sports programs aren't good enough to give them a chance to be seen. I saw Charlie Weis repeatedly at De Smet, as well as Gary Pinkel. Do you think they go downtown to recruit too?
Private schools aren't what you all assume. The comment about half of the students not being Catholic is downright wrong. There were VERY few students that weren't Catholic at De Smet (maybe 15 out of 1,200). Most of the kids that weren't were actually white and another form of Christian faith. Same was true of SLUH, CBC, and Vianney.
I've gone to private schools my entire life. I'm the fifth of seven kids, and we have all gone to private schools our entire lives. My parents aren't rich, and we struggled with payments for school. It was just something that we valued. My parents worked their asses off to be able to send us there. My mom is an elementary school teacher at a Catholic grade school. My Dad has a decent job working as a software engineer. They don't make a ton of money. We made sacrifices.
Don't go knocking people's life choices and values because you're pissed off that a local high school football team loses.
In Arkansas, nobody is allowed to recruit (though it doesn't stop anyone, public or private, from trying).
- BW23
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12896
- Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm
Re: Rave: High School Football
Well, that pretty much helps make my argument.Gantz57 wrote:They have talent, and going to a private school gives them a chance to make something of their life. What are they going to do with their lives coming from crappy inner city schools giving them a horrible education? Their sports programs aren't good enough to give them a chance to be seen. I saw Charlie Weis repeatedly at De Smet, as well as Gary Pinkel. Do you think they go downtown to recruit too?
I suggest going back to see what I said about this since I'm the one you're referring to. I didn't make mention of your school or the ones you mentioned. Here's what I said:Private schools aren't what you all assume. The comment about half of the students not being Catholic is downright wrong. There were VERY few students that weren't Catholic at De Smet (maybe 15 out of 1,200). Most of the kids that weren't were actually white and another form of Christian faith. Same was true of SLUH, CBC, and Vianney.
I'm going to go out on a limb and say that I know a lot more about this school than you do. And it's not going out on a limb to say that more than half of the students aren't Catholic. They may be this year, but they weren't the last two seasons. That's a fact.I'm sure the school Mike is talking about is different than the one close to me since very few, if any, minorities attend there (although I know of a handful they have recruited but not landed). I think something is wrong when this school is a state contender in every single sport they offer....except maybe girls track. I don't have a problem with parents that send their kids to this Catholic school for religious reasons (even though less than half of the kids are Catholic).
I'm not sure what this has to do with the argument that there should be a separate playoff system for private schools, but I'm glad you are happy with the education you received. To each their own. They're certainly not for me. There's no draw at all for me. There's only one way my child would ever attend a private school, and that circumstance is the longshot of longshots.I've gone to private schools my entire life. I'm the fifth of seven kids, and we have all gone to private schools our entire lives. My parents aren't rich, and we struggled with payments for school. It was just something that we valued. My parents worked their asses off to be able to send us there. My mom is an elementary school teacher at a Catholic grade school. My Dad has a decent job working as a software engineer. They don't make a ton of money. We made sacrifices.
I don't believe anyone here has knocked anyone's choice or values for attending a private school. I believe it's quite the opposite. And I'm not upset that my local high school football team lost. I expected it. My feelings on separate playoff systems hasn't changed in over a decade. One game certainly didn't sway me further to one side or the other. My local team beat the crap out of a private school that obviously recruits in the previous game, and I didn't suddenly start jumping up and down that things should stay the way they are now.Don't go knocking people's life choices and values because you're pissed off that a local high school football team loses.
Take a minute to go back and read what you were trying to reply to.
-
Freed Roger
- Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
- Posts: 26073
- Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
- Location: St. Louis
Re: Rave: High School Football
Don't many school districts give free choice? where you can go to whichever public high school you wish. So in a town like Peoria - football kids migrate to the football school, or the basketball school etc.
And I'm told that public schools do plenty of their own recruiting.
With a separate championship for public schools, in short time one would find plenty of inequities and things for parents to complain about.
And I'm told that public schools do plenty of their own recruiting.
With a separate championship for public schools, in short time one would find plenty of inequities and things for parents to complain about.
- Radbird
- There's someone in my head but it's not me
- Posts: 62390
- Joined: April 18 06, 5:08 pm
- Location: LF Bleachers @ Busch II
Re: Rave: High School Football
No problem. It's been so long that sometimes I forget myself.lukethedrifter wrote:Radbird wrote:WGHS Class of 1971 here.lukethedrifter wrote:The alma mater of Hungary Jack, pujolswrox, lukethedrifter and maybe new pagodi (I know there is at least one more WG alum here) won the Class 5 Mo State Football Championship.
Dammit. I knew that. Sorry.
In my mind you were a given and there's one more who I was trying to recall.
I think you're right, though, there's somebody we're forgetting.





