NFL 2010 Conference Championships

A forum for non-baseball sports
Post Reply
Online
Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21913
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: NFL 2010 Conference Championships

Post by Socnorb11 »

Now they're reporting that it's a sprained MCL.


Edit: Maybe that's the same as a tear........ I have no idea.

User avatar
Hungary Jack
Mother Earth
Posts: 19536
Joined: July 24 06, 6:03 am
Location: In Cognito

Re: NFL 2010 Conference Championships

Post by Hungary Jack »

TheoSqua wrote:Yeah, two other things are kind of missed here.

1.) Cutler was playing like suck. Sucky Cutler + Torn MCL = even suckier Cutler.

2.) The coaching staff pulled him, he didn't volunteer to leave the game. Obviously Lovie Smith decided his backup QBs would give him a better chance of winning than Cutler on a bad day with a shredded knee.

If Cutler were having the game of his life I bet he'd been in there a few more series.
And thus he gave us Todd Collins. For an entire quarter.

The Bears' inability to develop quarterback talent has always been a horse collar for the franchise. I never understood the fans' allergic reaction to Rex Grossman until I realized that he was carrying the burden of generations of failed quarterbacking in Chicago. That is why the Cutler trade induced so much excitement, and has now led to so much collective angst. He was horrible last year but has teased us this year with brilliant stretches. I haven't given up on Cutler, but he now has a mountain of PR issues to overcome. I don't think the demons get exorcised until he wins a championship.

The calls for Caleb Hanie to take the reins are ringing throughout Chicago. However, Hanie failed to read a zone blitz and delivered a perfect over the middle pass to a 335lb noseguard, giving him the thrill of a defensive lineman's lifetime. He's no savior.

User avatar
Hungary Jack
Mother Earth
Posts: 19536
Joined: July 24 06, 6:03 am
Location: In Cognito

Re: NFL 2010 Conference Championships

Post by Hungary Jack »

TheoSqua wrote:Yeah, two other things are kind of missed here.

1.) Cutler was playing like suck. Sucky Cutler + Torn MCL = even suckier Cutler.

2.) The coaching staff pulled him, he didn't volunteer to leave the game. Obviously Lovie Smith decided his backup QBs would give him a better chance of winning than Cutler on a bad day with a shredded knee.

If Cutler were having the game of his life I bet he'd been in there a few more series.
And thus he gave us Todd Collins. For an entire quarter.

The Bears' inability to develop quarterback talent has always been a horse collar for the franchise. I never understood the fans' allergic reaction to Rex Grossman until I realized that he was carrying the burden of generations of failed quarterbacking in Chicago. That is why the Cutler trade induced so much excitement, and has now led to so much collective angst. He was horrible last year but has teased us this year with brilliant stretches. I haven't given up on Cutler, but he now has a mountain of PR issues to overcome. I don't think the demons get exorcised until he wins a championship.

The calls for Caleb Hanie to take the reins are ringing throughout Chicago. However, Hanie failed to read a zone blitz and delivered a perfect over the middle pass to a 335lb noseguard, giving him the thrill of a defensive lineman's lifetime. He's no savior.

Online
Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21913
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: NFL 2010 Conference Championships

Post by Socnorb11 »

On a funny note, I heard a report on another message board that the MRI was inconclusive, because Cutler quit before it was over. :P

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: NFL 2010 Conference Championships

Post by jim »

When you blow out your ACL and require a year of rehab, you have "sprained" your knee. The term sprain is misunderstood. All sprains can be defined as:

Grade 1: Stretched ligament, no tears.
Grade 2: Some tearing but not complete.
Grade 3: Complete tear.

For an MCL, recovery times would be:
1: 0-1 week
2: 2-4 weeks
3: 6-8 weeks.

I grade III MCL tear is usually pretty painful and I would have expected him to be limping more. Like I said, if he had a mid-II or lower I would question him if he were my teammate in a game like that.

But I'll make one more comment .. the doc that did my kids surgery was on the Bengals staff some time ago. He told me that one misconception that people have is how bad of injuries these guys can play through. Arms, legs, fingers ...sure. But when it comes to the joints - the level of play is so hard that if you have anything more than a minor injury it's going to be tough to compete at that level. He said ankle and knee injuries that he has seen HS kids play through and excel with would sideline an NFL player. Reason is the talent disparity - some HS kids can still be effective at 75%. Even the best NFL player can't keep up at that level.

Online
Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21913
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: NFL 2010 Conference Championships

Post by Socnorb11 »

jim wrote:When you blow out your ACL and require a year of rehab, you have "sprained" your knee. The term sprain is misunderstood. All sprains can be defined as:

Grade 1: Stretched ligament, no tears.
Grade 2: Some tearing but not complete.
Grade 3: Complete tear.

For an MCL, recovery times would be:
1: 0-1 week
2: 2-4 weeks
3: 6-8 weeks.

I grade III MCL tear is usually pretty painful and I would have expected him to be limping more. Like I said, if he had a mid-II or lower I would question him if he were my teammate in a game like that.

But I'll make one more comment .. the doc that did my kids surgery was on the Bengals staff some time ago. He told me that one misconception that people have is how bad of injuries these guys can play through. Arms, legs, fingers ...sure. But when it comes to the joints - the level of play is so hard that if you have anything more than a minor injury it's going to be tough to compete at that level. He said ankle and knee injuries that he has seen HS kids play through and excel with would sideline an NFL player. Reason is the talent disparity - some HS kids can still be effective at 75%. Even the best NFL player can't keep up at that level.
So if there is a tear, would they likely specify that? Or not necessarily?

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: NFL 2010 Conference Championships

Post by jim »

Socnorb11 wrote: So if there is a tear, would they likely specify that? Or not necessarily?
With all of these laws about not giving out info and what not I have no idea. All I know is if someone tells you that he sprained his knee, that could literally be anywhere from no time missed to the end of his career. Depends on what he sprained and how bad he sprained it.

edit ... pitchers with that TJ surgery technically sprained their elbow to give you an idea.

User avatar
Richie Allen
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 7458
Joined: December 22 06, 1:06 am

Re: NFL 2010 Conference Championships

Post by Richie Allen »

thrill wrote:If you don't see why Cutler's potential is regarded so highly, you don't know anything about quarterbacks. He's by most scouts accounts, the second most physically gifted quarterback in the league behind Vick.
I know a successful quarterback when I see one and I've never seen it in Jay Cutler. He's far beyond prospect at this point in his development.

User avatar
thrill
bronoun enthusiast
Posts: 30539
Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
Location: barely online

Re: NFL 2010 Conference Championships

Post by thrill »

Richie Allen wrote:
thrill wrote:If you don't see why Cutler's potential is regarded so highly, you don't know anything about quarterbacks. He's by most scouts accounts, the second most physically gifted quarterback in the league behind Vick.
I know a successful quarterback when I see one and I've never seen it in Jay Cutler. He's far beyond prospect at this point in his development.
I'm distinguishing the difference between potential as talent and the likelihood that his attitude allows him to reach that potential.

User avatar
TheoSqua
Next Gen Wart
Posts: 8951
Joined: April 22 06, 6:53 pm
Location: St. Louis
Contact:

Re: NFL 2010 Conference Championships

Post by TheoSqua »

He's like the Victor Zambrano/A.J. Burnett type of football. Great stuff. Solid fastball and great two great secondary pitches. You think the guy would put up a 2.00 ERA and his inconsistent performances continue to baffle scouts. But big league clubs continue(d) to overpay for them due to his potential and the hope that one day he'll put it all together and be the best pitcher in baseball.

Post Reply