Malaysia Airlines flight missing

Chat about non-baseball topics. No political discussions!
Post Reply
Vidor
You've just been hit by...VidorSmarm™
Posts: 22956
Joined: June 10 10, 7:50 pm

Re: Malaysia Airlines flight missing

Post by Vidor »

Michael wrote:You say this, but there are experts that have not come to this same firm conclusion. A plane crash is a highly unusual event and there are very few people with actual expertise studying these types of failures. It wouldn't surprise me if there are feasible, but unintuitive, explanations for this crash that don't involve terrorism or suicide. That said, I don't think we should rule out those possibilities as well.
It's hard to square what we know with catastrophic failure. Turning the ACARS and transponder off 14 minutes apart, making a hard left turn across the peninsula into the Indian Ocean, flying for some five hours after contact was lost.

AdmiralKird wrote: The whole pilot/suicide angle really doesn't make sense to me. First you either have to have both pilots onboard agree to a suicide, or you have to murder the other one and the chief steward(ess), who has the keypad code to get into the cockpit, and then murder 200+ people by crashing the plane. That doesn't sound like something a person would do if they wanted to commit suicide unless they were absolutely mentally insane. It's really hard to get a posting to a large airliner like a 777, most pilots have to go through a long trade of smaller aircraft piloting just to get there.
That Egypt Air pilot crashed the plane on his own. Can't a pilot bolt the door, or does all the crew have some kind of key code? There isn't an override?
ghostrunner wrote:Whatever the reason it went down, it doesn't seem that weird to me that it can't be found. The most plausible explanation seem to me that it went off course and went down (intentionally or not), didn't break apart very much and the wreckage sank in a deep part of the ocean. I say that knowing jack squat about these kinds of things, but the only other explanation I can imagine is that it landed safely which seems highly implausible. If it exploded (bomb, missile, or failure) seems like debris would be floating around.
That's not surprising at all--they had a good idea of where the Air France plane should be from its ACARS and its flight path and it still took two years to find. This time the initial search was in the wrong place, and now they're looking over a huge hunk of the southeast Indian Ocean.

Michael
GRB Founder
Posts: 35304
Joined: December 31 69, 6:00 pm
Location: Chicago, IL
Contact:

Re: Malaysia Airlines flight missing

Post by Michael »

ghostrunner wrote:Whatever the reason it went down, it doesn't seem that weird to me that it can't be found. The most plausible explanation seem to me that it went off course and went down (intentionally or not), didn't break apart very much and the wreckage sank in a deep part of the ocean. I say that knowing jack squat about these kinds of things, but the only other explanation I can imagine is that it landed safely which seems highly implausible. If it exploded (bomb, missile, or failure) seems like debris would be floating around.
When Swissair Flight 111 hit the water it literally disintegrated:
The aircraft struck the ocean at 22:31 AT (01:31 UTC) at an estimated speed of 345 mph (555 km/h, 154 m/s, or 299 knots) and with a force of 350g, causing the aircraft to disintegrate[11] into millions of pieces.[12
Planes are made to be light, not to survive impacts. I remember certain truthers being skeptical by how little debris there was at the Pentagon, which was completely explainable.

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Malaysia Airlines flight missing

Post by jim »

Stupid question - is there any chance that the pilot depressurized the plane when he went to 45000 feet in a suicide attempt killing everyone on board, and then the damn thing just flew until it ran out of fuel x hours later? Maybe he diverted the path so it would just fall in the ocean.

Nothing makes sense, so I may as well ask.

Michael
GRB Founder
Posts: 35304
Joined: December 31 69, 6:00 pm
Location: Chicago, IL
Contact:

Re: Malaysia Airlines flight missing

Post by Michael »

Vidor wrote:It's hard to square what we know with catastrophic failure. Turning the ACARS and transponder off 14 minutes apart, making a hard left turn across the peninsula into the Indian Ocean, flying for some five hours after contact was lost.
Honest question - what do we know about catastrophic failure?

It's worth mentioning, today we found out there is debate regarding the ACARS timing:
But Malaysia Airlines CEO Ahmad Jauhari Yahya said today that authorities don’t know exactly when ACARS was disabled, according to The New York Times. The system, which transmits updates on a regular schedule, made its last transmission at 1:07 a.m. The next transmission should have occurred at 1:37, but did not. The pilot’s last communication was at 1:19 a.m.
Read more: http://www.politico.com/story/2014/0...#ixzz2wENSAomK


Again, I'm not saying it couldn't be something like suicide, but we shouldn't draw firm conclusions.

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30870
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: Malaysia Airlines flight missing

Post by ghostrunner »

Michael wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:Whatever the reason it went down, it doesn't seem that weird to me that it can't be found. The most plausible explanation seem to me that it went off course and went down (intentionally or not), didn't break apart very much and the wreckage sank in a deep part of the ocean. I say that knowing jack squat about these kinds of things, but the only other explanation I can imagine is that it landed safely which seems highly implausible. If it exploded (bomb, missile, or failure) seems like debris would be floating around.
When Swissair Flight 111 hit the water it literally disintegrated:
The aircraft struck the ocean at 22:31 AT (01:31 UTC) at an estimated speed of 345 mph (555 km/h, 154 m/s, or 299 knots) and with a force of 350g, causing the aircraft to disintegrate[11] into millions of pieces.[12
Planes are made to be light, not to survive impacts. I remember certain truthers being skeptical by how little debris there was with the Pentagon, which was thoroughly explainable.
Just as plausible, but they'd see at least some of those little pieces floating around wouldn't they? I have no idea though. Maybe too hard to see from above, and too remote to find easily by boat?

Gashouse
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 5010
Joined: June 15 06, 6:11 am
Location: Minneapolis

Re: Malaysia Airlines flight missing

Post by Gashouse »

A "soft" landing in the water like the Hudson River landing a few years ago wouldn't necessarily cause the plane to break up much. Then it could sink and leave little debris behind. Improbable, but...

Michael
GRB Founder
Posts: 35304
Joined: December 31 69, 6:00 pm
Location: Chicago, IL
Contact:

Re: Malaysia Airlines flight missing

Post by Michael »

ghostrunner wrote:Just as plausible, but they'd see at least some of those little pieces floating around wouldn't they? I have no idea though. Maybe too hard to see from above, and too remote to find easily by boat?
I'm no expert, but I do know we have trouble finding people lost at sea because they are so small. I assume this situation is even worse.

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Malaysia Airlines flight missing

Post by jim »

Or how about this theory based on my theme .. something was wrong mechanically with the plane, it depressurized killing everyone on board, and it just flew for a long time before it crashed.

Either way, my theory is it was a ghost plane for hours, with nobody alive in the plane. Is that possible?

User avatar
AdmiralKird
MBA, CPA, CFA, CFP, JD, PE, MD
Posts: 10178
Joined: March 7 07, 4:50 pm
Location: Tycho Crater, Luna

Re: Malaysia Airlines flight missing

Post by AdmiralKird »

jim wrote:Or how about this theory based on my theme .. something was wrong mechanically with the plane, it depressurized killing everyone on board, and it just flew for a long time before it crashed.

Either way, my theory is it was a ghost plane for hours, with nobody alive in the plane. Is that possible?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helios_Airways_Flight_522

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: Malaysia Airlines flight missing

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

Michael wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:Just as plausible, but they'd see at least some of those little pieces floating around wouldn't they? I have no idea though. Maybe too hard to see from above, and too remote to find easily by boat?
I'm no expert, but I do know we have trouble finding people lost at sea because they are so small. I assume this situation is even worse.
People just have a tough time understanding how vast and monotonous the ocean is because the scale of it is mindboggling.

But, just a quick point, think about this. The original USA Today graphic shown in this thread showed the plane possibly travelled up to another 2200 miles after losing contact (now they're saying possibly even further). If you convert that 2200 mile radius into square miles of earth to search, it's greater than 15 million square miles.

That's too much land to search. So, let's just assume they can eliminate 3/4 of that area (probably not, but just go with it). Cutting off 3/4 of the search area, the new condensed search area is just under 4 million square miles. To give an idea of how large that area still is, the United States of America is just under 4 million square miles.

Post Reply