Rant: Chain Restaurants

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
G. Keenan
Sucking on the Rally Nipple
Posts: 23719
Joined: April 16 06, 6:03 pm
Location: Chicago

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by G. Keenan »

Cronos69 wrote:
clement wrote: That's one of the big knocks on the US, especially outside of the most cosmopolitan cities, that you could be magically transported from one suburb to the next and you would have no idea if you were in Cincinnati, St. Louis, Salt Lake City, or Atlanta. Because they all look the same and have exactly the same stores and restaurants in the mall or Walmart shopping complex.
I was thinking about this post you made a few pages back today as I was wandering around both downtown and north of downtown Chicago, and though I'm biased in that this is the only major metropolitan place I've ever lived in, I've often told myself that the reason Chicago is impossible to navigate without the benefit of a map is because every street looks exactly the same as the next.

Apart from the fact that there aren't buildings taller than 20 feet, if I were so magically transported anywhere in the suburbs of Chicago I would have no hope of finding out where I happened to be, and from the major cities at least in the US I've visited (St. Louis, Chicago, NYC, Miami, San Diego, etc.), the only thing that distinguishes them that I can tell (apart from the obvious touristy stuff) is landscape, whether near a lake, plains, mountains, coast-side, etc.

My point is: the suburbs may all look the same, but I believe the city streets look all the same.
Chicago has to be one of the easiest cities to navigate in the world. Seriously. It's just a grid plus a few diagonals. As the numbers go up you are going north or west, as they go down you are going south or east. It's a piece of cake.

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by cards2468 »

G. Keenan wrote:
Cronos69 wrote:
clement wrote: That's one of the big knocks on the US, especially outside of the most cosmopolitan cities, that you could be magically transported from one suburb to the next and you would have no idea if you were in Cincinnati, St. Louis, Salt Lake City, or Atlanta. Because they all look the same and have exactly the same stores and restaurants in the mall or Walmart shopping complex.
I was thinking about this post you made a few pages back today as I was wandering around both downtown and north of downtown Chicago, and though I'm biased in that this is the only major metropolitan place I've ever lived in, I've often told myself that the reason Chicago is impossible to navigate without the benefit of a map is because every street looks exactly the same as the next.

Apart from the fact that there aren't buildings taller than 20 feet, if I were so magically transported anywhere in the suburbs of Chicago I would have no hope of finding out where I happened to be, and from the major cities at least in the US I've visited (St. Louis, Chicago, NYC, Miami, San Diego, etc.), the only thing that distinguishes them that I can tell (apart from the obvious touristy stuff) is landscape, whether near a lake, plains, mountains, coast-side, etc.

My point is: the suburbs may all look the same, but I believe the city streets look all the same.
Chicago has to be one of the easiest cities to navigate in the world. Seriously. It's just a grid plus a few diagonals. As the numbers go up you are going north or west, as they go down you are going south or east. It's a piece of cake.
So true. Most cities like this. Learn a few street names and you're set. I've only navigated Chicago a few times the past couple years, but it was pretty easy, all the way from Union Station up to Wrigleyville.

Try a city that is defined by the terrain and history, like Boston.


EDIT: Btw, CIncinnati is WAY different than those other cities. It has Skyline Chili, Gold Star Chili, and Dixie Chili... and all are [expletive] amazing.

User avatar
Richie Allen
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 7458
Joined: December 22 06, 1:06 am

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by Richie Allen »

G. Keenan wrote:
Cronos69 wrote:
clement wrote: That's one of the big knocks on the US, especially outside of the most cosmopolitan cities, that you could be magically transported from one suburb to the next and you would have no idea if you were in Cincinnati, St. Louis, Salt Lake City, or Atlanta. Because they all look the same and have exactly the same stores and restaurants in the mall or Walmart shopping complex.
I was thinking about this post you made a few pages back today as I was wandering around both downtown and north of downtown Chicago, and though I'm biased in that this is the only major metropolitan place I've ever lived in, I've often told myself that the reason Chicago is impossible to navigate without the benefit of a map is because every street looks exactly the same as the next.

Apart from the fact that there aren't buildings taller than 20 feet, if I were so magically transported anywhere in the suburbs of Chicago I would have no hope of finding out where I happened to be, and from the major cities at least in the US I've visited (St. Louis, Chicago, NYC, Miami, San Diego, etc.), the only thing that distinguishes them that I can tell (apart from the obvious touristy stuff) is landscape, whether near a lake, plains, mountains, coast-side, etc.

My point is: the suburbs may all look the same, but I believe the city streets look all the same.
Chicago has to be one of the easiest cities to navigate in the world. Seriously. It's just a grid plus a few diagonals. As the numbers go up you are going north or west, as they go down you are going south or east. It's a piece of cake.
I was going to say the same thing. I only go there a few times a year but I've never gotten lost, although there's been numerous times I've had no idea where in the hell I was, and probably wouldn't ever think to consult a map. St. Louis, on the other hand...

User avatar
Cronos
In perpetuum
Posts: 34778
Joined: June 30 06, 7:49 am
Location: St. Louis

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by Cronos »

G. Keenan wrote:
Cronos69 wrote:
clement wrote: That's one of the big knocks on the US, especially outside of the most cosmopolitan cities, that you could be magically transported from one suburb to the next and you would have no idea if you were in Cincinnati, St. Louis, Salt Lake City, or Atlanta. Because they all look the same and have exactly the same stores and restaurants in the mall or Walmart shopping complex.
I was thinking about this post you made a few pages back today as I was wandering around both downtown and north of downtown Chicago, and though I'm biased in that this is the only major metropolitan place I've ever lived in, I've often told myself that the reason Chicago is impossible to navigate without the benefit of a map is because every street looks exactly the same as the next.

Apart from the fact that there aren't buildings taller than 20 feet, if I were so magically transported anywhere in the suburbs of Chicago I would have no hope of finding out where I happened to be, and from the major cities at least in the US I've visited (St. Louis, Chicago, NYC, Miami, San Diego, etc.), the only thing that distinguishes them that I can tell (apart from the obvious touristy stuff) is landscape, whether near a lake, plains, mountains, coast-side, etc.

My point is: the suburbs may all look the same, but I believe the city streets look all the same.
Chicago has to be one of the easiest cities to navigate in the world. Seriously. It's just a grid plus a few diagonals. As the numbers go up you are going north or west, as they go down you are going south or east. It's a piece of cake.


But that's what makes it look like any other city, is my point.

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30870
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by ghostrunner »

clement wrote: I can certainly understand that and I shop in Borders as well. But places like Borders/Barnes & Noble have in fact put very large, very well-stocked locally owned independent bookstores out of business. Maybe not in small-town Indiana, but in larger metropolitan areas for sure. Furthermore, the idea of having a giant bookstore is only great in a community where you drive everywhere (same goes for Target, Wal-Mart, etc... Hypermarkets, Supermarkets). So all of this development just solidifies our addiction to and reliance on the automobile and to continuing to build environmentally unsustainable communities.
I don't see what's so unsustainable about it. It's simply different. So we take individual vehicles. Why not just improve those to the point where they're environmentally friendly and themselves recyclable or have longer lifespans? I don't see what's so wrong with driving cars, in and of itself. Given the current state of things, which grew "organically" here in the states, it makes more sense to me to work with what we've already built rather than trying to retrofit everything to some debatable ideal.

I'm not sure what's supposed to be done about these big stores. If the giant bookstore was only a good idea in places where you have to drive, why do they do so well in large cities with mass transit? If people value the small stores in the same way you do, they will continue to shop there. But clearly enough people don't care, and so the community has decided it likes the big stores as well.

At least in the case of bookstores, I'd argue the big chains offer a better experience. Before we moved to Texas, my wife and I lived in a 50K college town in NC. We weren't big into bar hopping, so we'd hang out at the Barnes and Noble until closing. You could get a stack going from a wide variety of books and just sit and read, and the bookstore didn't care. Just by being there regularly, you were more likely to buy something from them. I always thought it was kind of a cool business model. Until they arrived, all we had was two mall bookstores that always seemed empty and a couple of used paperback places.

User avatar
Richie Allen
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 7458
Joined: December 22 06, 1:06 am

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by Richie Allen »

I agree that many of the small bookstores, especially the really depressing ones at malls (which are also chains, by the way), are nothing to get too excited about. And, for the most part, the addition of Borders and Barnes & Noble have benefited many communities. But, in my opinion, these may fall into the category of the exception, rather than the rule, when it comes to giant chains. These stores, by nature, appeal to the artier community. They recognize the desire to take your time while you're contemplating a purchase or even sit down and browse through their books. They're not the best, but they do a pretty good job of making your visit comfortable. Perhaps, if more chains followed models similar to these (if possible) we might not see so many complaints across the board about "Big Food" and others. But the fact that there are exceptions to the rule doesn't mean the complaints about other large chain stores are not valid.

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by jim »

G. Keenan wrote:
Cronos69 wrote:
clement wrote: That's one of the big knocks on the US, especially outside of the most cosmopolitan cities, that you could be magically transported from one suburb to the next and you would have no idea if you were in Cincinnati, St. Louis, Salt Lake City, or Atlanta. Because they all look the same and have exactly the same stores and restaurants in the mall or Walmart shopping complex.
I was thinking about this post you made a few pages back today as I was wandering around both downtown and north of downtown Chicago, and though I'm biased in that this is the only major metropolitan place I've ever lived in, I've often told myself that the reason Chicago is impossible to navigate without the benefit of a map is because every street looks exactly the same as the next.

Apart from the fact that there aren't buildings taller than 20 feet, if I were so magically transported anywhere in the suburbs of Chicago I would have no hope of finding out where I happened to be, and from the major cities at least in the US I've visited (St. Louis, Chicago, NYC, Miami, San Diego, etc.), the only thing that distinguishes them that I can tell (apart from the obvious touristy stuff) is landscape, whether near a lake, plains, mountains, coast-side, etc.

My point is: the suburbs may all look the same, but I believe the city streets look all the same.
Chicago has to be one of the easiest cities to navigate in the world. Seriously. It's just a grid plus a few diagonals. As the numbers go up you are going north or west, as they go down you are going south or east. It's a piece of cake.

State/Madison = the origin and go from there. That's the easy part. The hard part isn't how to get there, it's actually doing it. Chicago is a freaking nightmare of a place to get around, and the public transportation is at best mediocre.

User avatar
clement
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 6008
Joined: April 20 06, 10:26 pm

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by clement »

ghostrunner wrote:
clement wrote: I can certainly understand that and I shop in Borders as well. But places like Borders/Barnes & Noble have in fact put very large, very well-stocked locally owned independent bookstores out of business. Maybe not in small-town Indiana, but in larger metropolitan areas for sure. Furthermore, the idea of having a giant bookstore is only great in a community where you drive everywhere (same goes for Target, Wal-Mart, etc... Hypermarkets, Supermarkets). So all of this development just solidifies our addiction to and reliance on the automobile and to continuing to build environmentally unsustainable communities.
I don't see what's so unsustainable about it. It's simply different. So we take individual vehicles. Why not just improve those to the point where they're environmentally friendly and themselves recyclable or have longer lifespans? I don't see what's so wrong with driving cars, in and of itself. Given the current state of things, which grew "organically" here in the states, it makes more sense to me to work with what we've already built rather than trying to retrofit everything to some debatable ideal.
Forgive me if I'm just a little skeptical of us "just improving" automobiles, but I've been hearing about this for about 40 of my 44 years and so far I don't see it happening. And the automobile-centered lifestyle that grew in the states was not "organic".
I'm not sure what's supposed to be done about these big stores. If the giant bookstore was only a good idea in places where you have to drive, why do they do so well in large cities with mass transit? If people value the small stores in the same way you do, they will continue to shop there. But clearly enough people don't care, and so the community has decided it likes the big stores as well.
There are any number of things that can be done, but your assumption is incorrect. There are not nearly as many "big" stores in urban areas. People like big stores primarily because of the cheaper prices and the big store chains, much like the chain restaurants are able to capitalize on economies of scale that independent shops cannot.
At least in the case of bookstores, I'd argue the big chains offer a better experience. Before we moved to Texas, my wife and I lived in a 50K college town in NC. We weren't big into bar hopping, so we'd hang out at the Barnes and Noble until closing. You could get a stack going from a wide variety of books and just sit and read, and the bookstore didn't care. Just by being there regularly, you were more likely to buy something from them. I always thought it was kind of a cool business model. Until they arrived, all we had was two mall bookstores that always seemed empty and a couple of used paperback places.
Like I said before, small towns might not have had anything worthy before Borders arrived, but larger urban areas did.

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30870
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by ghostrunner »

clement wrote:
ghostrunner wrote:
clement wrote: I can certainly understand that and I shop in Borders as well. But places like Borders/Barnes & Noble have in fact put very large, very well-stocked locally owned independent bookstores out of business. Maybe not in small-town Indiana, but in larger metropolitan areas for sure. Furthermore, the idea of having a giant bookstore is only great in a community where you drive everywhere (same goes for Target, Wal-Mart, etc... Hypermarkets, Supermarkets). So all of this development just solidifies our addiction to and reliance on the automobile and to continuing to build environmentally unsustainable communities.
I don't see what's so unsustainable about it. It's simply different. So we take individual vehicles. Why not just improve those to the point where they're environmentally friendly and themselves recyclable or have longer lifespans? I don't see what's so wrong with driving cars, in and of itself. Given the current state of things, which grew "organically" here in the states, it makes more sense to me to work with what we've already built rather than trying to retrofit everything to some debatable ideal.
Forgive me if I'm just a little skeptical of us "just improving" automobiles, but I've been hearing about this for about 40 of my 44 years and so far I don't see it happening. And the automobile-centered lifestyle that grew in the states was not "organic".
I'm not sure what's supposed to be done about these big stores. If the giant bookstore was only a good idea in places where you have to drive, why do they do so well in large cities with mass transit? If people value the small stores in the same way you do, they will continue to shop there. But clearly enough people don't care, and so the community has decided it likes the big stores as well.
There are any number of things that can be done, but your assumption is incorrect. There are not nearly as many "big" stores in urban areas. People like big stores primarily because of the cheaper prices and the big store chains, much like the chain restaurants are able to capitalize on economies of scale that independent shops cannot.

The US has been spread out from the beginning, and also has a pretty strong individualist strain. People expanded across the country by themselves and covered territory much faster than they ever did in Europe. People went long distances just to grab their own piece of land away from other people. I think it's fair to say the automobile grew out of that to some extent. In part cars replaced horses, which were individually owned long distance vehicles.

And cars have improved significantly, so I don't see the big obstacle there. If we can get them powered electrically, that seems acceptable to me until we can get something even better. Destroying what's already been built in order to encourage people to travel differently doesn't strike me as a good idea. You could put a rail service at all major intersections of indianapolis, and it's still not usable for many people given the layout of most American cities. You'd just end up driving to the rail stop.

I never said there were as many big chains in the cities. But they are there and doing fine. You suggested they were only a good idea if you travel by car, but obviously plenty of city dwellers disagree.

User avatar
clement
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 6008
Joined: April 20 06, 10:26 pm

Re: Rant: Chain Restaurants

Post by clement »

US cities used to be like cities everywhere else in the world. Then there was a huge move to creating suburbs (around the 1950s and forward) which was largely pushed by the automobile industry, and was facilitated by the white flight phenomenon. Sure, the US is a big spread out country and people used to ride horses, but that doesn't explain why Americans who lived in cities suddenly began to spread out into suburbs in the 1950s. GM bought train and trolley tracks all over the country and dismantled them, for example. You can call it shrewd marketing I guess, but they basically rendered public transit systems in many American cities inoperable or completely unpleasant, pushing people to just opt for buying their automobiles instead.

I didn't say that chains were only a good idea if people travel by car, I said that relying on big chain stores to buy our goods further pushes our dependence on cars since they tend to locate in cheaper rent suburban areas. And sure, many of them do well in cities too... I don't want to keep repeating myself, but I am not for a second denying that these businesses do well. They are more cost efficient and capitalize on economies of scale. So they don't have to do as well in terms of margins as independent stores, whether they are big or small. They have a competitive advantage by definition.

And I'm not suggesting that we destroy existing cities, I'm saying that we should stop exacerbating a problem that has been going on for 50 years and getting worse and worse and start to reverse the trend by investing in building communities that make more sense. What's wrong with having people drive to rail stations? That's how it's done for suburban commuters in most cities that have a half-way decent rail system. It probably cuts down on traffic and emissions by well over 50% than if they drove the whole distance.

Post Reply