Socnorb11 wrote:Unions are literarlly giving hundreds of millions of dollars to politicians. For what? What legislation has helped union members in the last 20 years? Someone is getting rich, but it's not union members.
I'd be willing to bet they are often blocking legislation that would loosen work place safety laws and work hour restrictions.
Do you think we have child labor laws cause it's moral? Minimum wage? Michelle Bachmann wants to do away with both!
OSHA was enacted in 1970, so it was a little more than 20 years ago, but still a modern victory for unions. Collective bargaining is one of the few pieces of leverage American's have against their employer.
planet pujolsian wrote: It's ridiculous that you don't understand you're part of the "members", regardless of whether you belong to a union or not. I'm sure there's wasted money going towards political campaigns, but how else do people make a living, respectable wage? It goes far beyond passing legislation for banning child labor, etc. Have you checked out the astronomically growing inequity in the country? Feel free to feel sorry for these people, but if the shoe was on the other foot, you'd be up in arms.
Unions are literarlly giving hundreds of millions of dollars to politicians. For what? What legislation has helped union members in the last 20 years? Someone is getting rich, but it's not union members.
Corporations are giving hundreds of millions of dollars to politicians to try to break the unions (ie: Wisconsin, Right to Work states, etc)...so what's your point?
My point is that there's corruption everywhere, and I believe that union leadership isn't really an exception.
planet pujolsian wrote: It's ridiculous that you don't understand you're part of the "members", regardless of whether you belong to a union or not. I'm sure there's wasted money going towards political campaigns, but how else do people make a living, respectable wage? It goes far beyond passing legislation for banning child labor, etc. Have you checked out the astronomically growing inequity in the country? Feel free to feel sorry for these people, but if the shoe was on the other foot, you'd be up in arms.
Unions are literarlly giving hundreds of millions of dollars to politicians. For what? What legislation has helped union members in the last 20 years? Someone is getting rich, but it's not union members.
Corporations are giving hundreds of millions of dollars to politicians to try to break the unions (ie: Wisconsin, Right to Work states, etc)...so what's your point?
My point is that there's corruption everywhere, and I believe that union leadership isn't really an exception.
Well, that I can agree on...but it's been like that forever, it isn't anything new.
The original premise was that unions are the answer for middle class. That's a slippery slope. Giving anyone (including unions) too much power isn't going to solve the problems for the middle class. Union leadership needs to be held accountable, as well.
Socnorb11 wrote:TFG and Vin - I agree with you both.
The original premise was that unions are the answer for middle class. That's a slippery slope. Giving anyone (including unions) too much power isn't going to solve the problems for the middle class. Union leadership needs to be held accountable, as well.
I'm not too smart at this stuff but if unions aren't good for the middle class why have corporations destroyed unions at the same time the corporate controlled government has destroyed the middle class?
Just a coincidence.
Unions are bad for you but depleting the treasury to fight several wars and bail out failed banks, allowing jobs to go to workers overseas, creating unemployment causing young people from poor families to enlist in the military and play the survival lottery, those are all good for you- especially if the wealthy don't have to pay taxes, because they will buy stuff and a few of you can work as cashiers in retail stores.
slide_into_first wrote:Unions are bad for you but depleting the treasury to fight several wars and bail out failed banks, allowing jobs to go to workers overseas, creating unemployment causing young people from poor families to enlist in the military and play the survival lottery, those are all good for you- especially if the wealthy don't have to pay taxes, because they will buy stuff and a few of you can work as cashiers in retail stores.
I'm opposed to all of those things, slide.
My only point is that unions aren't preventing those things from happening, despite their members giving hundreds of millions of dollar to politicians. I'm not convinced that union leadership (AFL-CIO, for example) is helping their members. Personally, I'd just as soon put that money back into the pockets of the working man, rather than fork it over to politicians.