Money and debt
- Bo Hart
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 8770
- Joined: April 14 06, 9:50 pm
Re: Money and debt
My minimum monthly payments for my student loans are $308. However, being that I'm just starting to pay them off, a nauseatingly-high percent of that is just knocking out interest that's accumulating each month (something like $140 of the $308 goes towards interest). So I've decided that I'm pumping $1000/month into those loans until they're paid off; this basically means I have no expendable income to put towards a house, car, etc... oh well, I'm sure it'll be worth it in the end.
- Joe Shlabotnik
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 24292
- Joined: October 12 06, 2:21 pm
- Location: Baseball Ref Bullpen
- Contact:
Re: Money and debt
Smart. Very smart.Kyle wrote:My minimum monthly payments for my student loans are $308. However, being that I'm just starting to pay them off, a nauseatingly-high percent of that is just knocking out interest that's accumulating each month (something like $140 of the $308 goes towards interest). So I've decided that I'm pumping $1000/month into those loans until they're paid off; this basically means I have no expendable income to put towards a house, car, etc... oh well, I'm sure it'll be worth it in the end.
- Hungary Jack
- Mother Earth
- Posts: 19536
- Joined: July 24 06, 6:03 am
- Location: In Cognito
Re: Money and debt
Perhaps the thing I remember most that I heard in class in business school was that it's not how much you make, but how much you spend that determines your ability to accumulate wealth.
Obviously this has its limits, but the point is crystal clear: live well within your means, and you will have means to live well, because debt sucks.
Marriage is a partnership on many levels: romantic, emotional, social, professional, economic, financial etc. I think the financial dimension is critically important to a harmonious one, and it has been a source of friction for Mrs. Jack and I from time to time. She earns a very good living, but is not afraid to spend it. Her habits have changed quite a bit, but we still differ markedly in our behaviors. I have never really made a lot of money--6 figures on a few occasions--but I feel I have been very rich in life experience by being really opportunistic (living in Budapest a year; taking long backpack trips; hiking and skiing in Colorado; etc.) at times. No amount of money could ever compensate the loss of these experiences.
So ghost, I hope your spouse understands the partnership and you guys can find ways to make it work.
Obviously this has its limits, but the point is crystal clear: live well within your means, and you will have means to live well, because debt sucks.
Marriage is a partnership on many levels: romantic, emotional, social, professional, economic, financial etc. I think the financial dimension is critically important to a harmonious one, and it has been a source of friction for Mrs. Jack and I from time to time. She earns a very good living, but is not afraid to spend it. Her habits have changed quite a bit, but we still differ markedly in our behaviors. I have never really made a lot of money--6 figures on a few occasions--but I feel I have been very rich in life experience by being really opportunistic (living in Budapest a year; taking long backpack trips; hiking and skiing in Colorado; etc.) at times. No amount of money could ever compensate the loss of these experiences.
So ghost, I hope your spouse understands the partnership and you guys can find ways to make it work.
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31097
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: Money and debt
Well since I put an offer in on a house today, I'm of course feelin' it in regards to money and debt. I've never been overly nervous about my own spending and keeping it under control. I'm able to determine what I'm able to spend, what I shouldn't, and keep everything in check. This is the first time I'm extending beyond what I would for myself so that I can please the wishes of someone else. As in, if it were up to just me, I wouldn't be spending nearly this much on a house. So this makes me very nervous today. And I'm nervous for the future as I know that *I'll* be able to keep my spending in check as needed to afford this new bigger house payment, but I'm not sure if the ol' lady friend will be able to. She has a tendency to spend more on the little stuff--groceries, going out to eat more than we should, etc. It all adds up, quickly.
- vinsanity
- Chili dog truther
- Posts: 8836
- Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
- Location: Indianapolis
Re: Money and debt
I think a house or retirement would be a bit better, but I love this game and squeezing every last percentage point of interest out of money I can. I'm one of those [expletive] that would borrow $5k against my house at 5% to fund my Roth. (I can always pull the principle out the Roth, penalty free to pay off the HELOC if interest rates went up).Joe Shlabotnik wrote:Smart. Very smart.Kyle wrote:My minimum monthly payments for my student loans are $308. However, being that I'm just starting to pay them off, a nauseatingly-high percent of that is just knocking out interest that's accumulating each month (something like $140 of the $308 goes towards interest). So I've decided that I'm pumping $1000/month into those loans until they're paid off; this basically means I have no expendable income to put towards a house, car, etc... oh well, I'm sure it'll be worth it in the end.
Kyle, I'm not sure what kind of retirement plans you got or what you do or what kinda interest you have on your loans, but I think we were in school around the same time. I've got somewhere around $120k in student loans and I'm on strict interest only for right now for about $400/month. That means not a dime is going to principle (woulda been $900/month and my first job didn't pay well enough for that). But interest on the vast majority of mine is near 3% and that's tax deductible making the effective rate around 2% or closer to inflation - which makes it nearly free money.
So say you put an extra $12k a year towards student loans to save 2% in interest vs earning closer 10%/year by putting it in a market tracking fund. This only works until til your Modified Adjusted Gross Income is <$75k but while it doesn't sound like much, that extra 8% on the $12k in 40+ years ends up making a few hundred thousand.
This only really works with stupid low student loan interest. Once you get closer to 5 or 6 or 7% it's not as big of a deal. And, especially as the numbers get closer together, the feeling of being debt free can be more valuable than hitting your $1M retirement goal 6 months earlier.
Just food for thought; if the money's cheap, use your money to make more than the loan is costin ya.
-
planet planet
- http://tinyurl.com/2e4x5hy
- Posts: 24904
- Joined: April 15 06, 6:25 pm
- Location: St. Louis
Re: Money and debt
I think every SO/spouse thinks their SO/spouse spends more than they should. It usually boils down to different spending priorities. Not trying to sterotype, but in my experience men seem to drop cash on high dollar items like electronics, etc. whereas women will spend smaller increments on clothes, going out to dinner, etc., but more frequently so it "feels" like they're spending more. The bottom line is most people income's don't go as far as they used to pre-bust which is to be expected (not directed towards you, Popeye). That's understandable given the job losses and wage stagnation we've experienced over the last decade.Popeye_Card wrote:Well since I put an offer in on a house today, I'm of course feelin' it in regards to money and debt. I've never been overly nervous about my own spending and keeping it under control. I'm able to determine what I'm able to spend, what I shouldn't, and keep everything in check. This is the first time I'm extending beyond what I would for myself so that I can please the wishes of someone else. As in, if it were up to just me, I wouldn't be spending nearly this much on a house. So this makes me very nervous today. And I'm nervous for the future as I know that *I'll* be able to keep my spending in check as needed to afford this new bigger house payment, but I'm not sure if the ol' lady friend will be able to. She has a tendency to spend more on the little stuff--groceries, going out to eat more than we should, etc. It all adds up, quickly.
And to answer your question, Freed, we do joint checking as well and I've asked other married couples what they do as it's an interesting topic. Most of the separate check account people seem to get defensive when asked. It'd be an interesting experiment if one party seems to consistently overspend, but not so sure how healthy it would be on the marriage.
Popeye, the upgrade in house expenditure looks to be the right move if you can afford it with your spending habits alone or if your gf is contributing and it makes you both happy.
- thrill
- bronoun enthusiast
- Posts: 30539
- Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
- Location: barely online
Re: Money and debt
My problem is that I have been in a weird accumulation mode for the past 4 years. I was dead ass broke for 4 years after high school and a lot of the time had to choose between eating a decent meal and having deodorant and once I got a decent job it was like I was surrounding myself with everything (laptop, iphone, clothes, tv, nice mattress, shoes and luxuries like expensive sunglasses, cologne, expensive headphones, eating out all the time) I could afford to feel some sense of security.
In actuality I'd be more secure saving. I just have to get into that mindset.
In actuality I'd be more secure saving. I just have to get into that mindset.
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30873
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: Money and debt
My wife is a peach, all things considered. Not any real issues there. Mostly just stuff I know she's thinking. Neither of us gets to spend that much, she just has more stuff she wants to do. And in her defense, most of it is home improvement stuff that does need to happen. She starts thinking about too much at once, and gets pretty down when we can't do any of it. Which gets me down.
I think loving my job would alleviate some of this, but the problem is that I don't and taking the steps to get there is too big a financial risk if it doesn't pay off. Teaching is a good example. I'd have to quit working for a while and teachers are being laid off here. I think this programming thing will work if I stick to it. I like it, it's easy to teach myself, and demand is sky-high from what I understand.
Outside of our house I don't know if we even have that much debt relative to other people. The non-house debt is probably about 30% of our yearly income. It's been growing lately though to cover some things that have come up, and we're still recovering from my wife being unemployed for a year. We just have very little room to save or even buy basic stuff beyond groceries or gas.
Most of the time I'm in good spirits, but this is just one of those times where the [expletive] seems to be piling up. Thanks for the kind words.
Theo - I'd highly encourage you to try and cut costs on that wedding where possible. I assume it's your wedding? Unless you think you can recover easily enough, starting a marriage in debt seems like a bad idea. I don't know the specifics though, so I don't want to proselytize too much. It's like accepted dogma now that it's "her day" so people go crazy with that stuff, but it's also both of your lives.
I think loving my job would alleviate some of this, but the problem is that I don't and taking the steps to get there is too big a financial risk if it doesn't pay off. Teaching is a good example. I'd have to quit working for a while and teachers are being laid off here. I think this programming thing will work if I stick to it. I like it, it's easy to teach myself, and demand is sky-high from what I understand.
Outside of our house I don't know if we even have that much debt relative to other people. The non-house debt is probably about 30% of our yearly income. It's been growing lately though to cover some things that have come up, and we're still recovering from my wife being unemployed for a year. We just have very little room to save or even buy basic stuff beyond groceries or gas.
Most of the time I'm in good spirits, but this is just one of those times where the [expletive] seems to be piling up. Thanks for the kind words.
Theo - I'd highly encourage you to try and cut costs on that wedding where possible. I assume it's your wedding? Unless you think you can recover easily enough, starting a marriage in debt seems like a bad idea. I don't know the specifics though, so I don't want to proselytize too much. It's like accepted dogma now that it's "her day" so people go crazy with that stuff, but it's also both of your lives.
- a_smith
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 4561
- Joined: September 20 06, 10:55 am
Re: Money and debt
nice thread.
couldn't agree more with Hungary.
Vinsanity knows his [expletive]. while you might not earn 10% you can earn more than what you are paying for interest.
it might be better for you to pay that off early. Not necessarily. Might be worth consulting an accountant.
I consolidated my loans in 2006 just before they changed the rules and with a few on time payments I am down to (not kidding) less than 1% interest. No freaking way I am paying that off early. I put money away that I planned on paying my loan and am much better off.
we both are cheap and don't spend a lot of money that is unneeded. we are insanely compatible financially. we are also competitive savers.
I wouldnt do it if we weren't incredibly similar in our habits. I know way too many people who got into ruin because a spouse had a secret addiction.
thrill- man, do i get buying things once you get a job. I was there. After a decade of being an ass broke grad student it was great to have a car that didnt break down. Decent food. Being able to go out to eat when you wanted. I got that stuff.
After a while I realized that I didnt need any more stuff. That itch was scratched.
I was also conscious to not acquire the tastes of a person who had a lifestyle that I couldn't support.
couldn't agree more with Hungary.
Vinsanity knows his [expletive]. while you might not earn 10% you can earn more than what you are paying for interest.
it might be better for you to pay that off early. Not necessarily. Might be worth consulting an accountant.
I consolidated my loans in 2006 just before they changed the rules and with a few on time payments I am down to (not kidding) less than 1% interest. No freaking way I am paying that off early. I put money away that I planned on paying my loan and am much better off.
yes. we split bills. It does make it clear who spends what and who is saving what.Freed Roger wrote: Am curious, does anybody do separate checking from their spouses (their money and your money)? We don't, but sometimes I wonder if it would clarify a few things.
we both are cheap and don't spend a lot of money that is unneeded. we are insanely compatible financially. we are also competitive savers.
I wouldnt do it if we weren't incredibly similar in our habits. I know way too many people who got into ruin because a spouse had a secret addiction.
thrill- man, do i get buying things once you get a job. I was there. After a decade of being an ass broke grad student it was great to have a car that didnt break down. Decent food. Being able to go out to eat when you wanted. I got that stuff.
After a while I realized that I didnt need any more stuff. That itch was scratched.
I was also conscious to not acquire the tastes of a person who had a lifestyle that I couldn't support.
- AdmiralKird
- MBA, CPA, CFA, CFP, JD, PE, MD
- Posts: 10179
- Joined: March 7 07, 4:50 pm
- Location: Tycho Crater, Luna
Re: Money and debt
Not necessarily, you can generally earn more interest on an investment account in excess of your student loans (usually around 6.5%). A diversified equities and bond account should net you around 9.5% a year. In this scenario, you'd be better of making the lowest loan payments possible and investing the rest.Joe Shlabotnik wrote:Smart. Very smart.Kyle wrote:My minimum monthly payments for my student loans are $308. However, being that I'm just starting to pay them off, a nauseatingly-high percent of that is just knocking out interest that's accumulating each month (something like $140 of the $308 goes towards interest). So I've decided that I'm pumping $1000/month into those loans until they're paid off; this basically means I have no expendable income to put towards a house, car, etc... oh well, I'm sure it'll be worth it in the end.



