Randy Shannon is out
- clevername
- Bringer of FRBG
- Posts: 10380
- Joined: April 16 06, 7:13 pm
- Location: Alabama
Re: Randy Shannon is out
the good class in 08 was the anomaly. Like I said, you have good recruits fall into your lap in that area, so they'll always have top 25 classes, but the amount of talent he let go just from the Miami area in the past few years has hurt.
-
phins
- Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
- Posts: 12085
- Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm
Re: Randy Shannon is out
Clevername is right, Shannon had that one class, and otherwise has been a poor recruiter. He'll always get decent classes, it's Miami. Miami can get ANY kid they want from Miami Northwestern, one of the best high school programs in America (8 came from that '08 class).
My top choice would be Patterson. Experience recruiting against bigger budget state schools in a fertile recruiting area, and experience elevating a program from previous levels. I don't think he leaves now that they're supposed to go to Big East.
Gruden isn't coming to Miami, I have that on pretty good word.
Next choice would be Brett Bielema. He has ties to Miami's President.
My next choice would be Dan Mullen. I haven't heard him as a candidate though.
If you want my prediction, I think it will be Mike Stoops. Our AD was at K-State with him, he'd jump at the job, Miami probably isn't going to pay the $3 million it will take to lure a big time guy, and his brother Mark has ties to Miami as a former position coach. It would be an underwhelming hire to me.
Was the self-righteous comment directed at me? I'm OT reveling in a man who loves the U probably more than I do losing his job, but I do feel it was time for him to go (obviously).
My top choice would be Patterson. Experience recruiting against bigger budget state schools in a fertile recruiting area, and experience elevating a program from previous levels. I don't think he leaves now that they're supposed to go to Big East.
Gruden isn't coming to Miami, I have that on pretty good word.
Next choice would be Brett Bielema. He has ties to Miami's President.
My next choice would be Dan Mullen. I haven't heard him as a candidate though.
If you want my prediction, I think it will be Mike Stoops. Our AD was at K-State with him, he'd jump at the job, Miami probably isn't going to pay the $3 million it will take to lure a big time guy, and his brother Mark has ties to Miami as a former position coach. It would be an underwhelming hire to me.
Was the self-righteous comment directed at me? I'm OT reveling in a man who loves the U probably more than I do losing his job, but I do feel it was time for him to go (obviously).
- clevername
- Bringer of FRBG
- Posts: 10380
- Joined: April 16 06, 7:13 pm
- Location: Alabama
Re: Randy Shannon is out
I've seen Mullen mentioned elsewhere, but I think it's still just fan speculation at this point.
Peter King, Adam Schefter, and Jon Gruden himself have said he's not going to UM.
This am I'm reading about Mark Richt, which makes sense but I'm not sure he wants to go back, Marc Trestman (as a rival fan this is who I'm hoping for), and Jim Leavitt.
Peter King, Adam Schefter, and Jon Gruden himself have said he's not going to UM.
This am I'm reading about Mark Richt, which makes sense but I'm not sure he wants to go back, Marc Trestman (as a rival fan this is who I'm hoping for), and Jim Leavitt.
- Transmogrified Tiger
- Puppy Murderer
- Posts: 9323
- Joined: April 25 06, 6:07 pm
- Location: Across the River
Re: Randy Shannon is out
I was going to make a hilarious "He wouldn't want to go to a worse conference" joke here, but I forgot and now TCU ruined it.clevername wrote:If I were Miami I'd be going after a more established college coach like Gary Patterson.
- JL21
- NPR & THT Contributor
- Posts: 36109
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
- Location: Chocolate City
Re: Randy Shannon is out
Yes. They have ties... through the University of Wisconsin. Bielema isn't going anywhere.phins wrote:Next choice would be Brett Bielema. He has ties to Miami's President.
- cARdsfan
- Veteran Player
- Posts: 546
- Joined: May 30 06, 2:08 pm
- Location: Johnsonville, SC
Re: Randy Shannon is out
I've also heard mention of Gus Malzahn.
I'll go ahead and throw this out there so I look brilliant later - Rich Rodriguez
I'll go ahead and throw this out there so I look brilliant later - Rich Rodriguez
-
phins
- Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
- Posts: 12085
- Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm
Re: Randy Shannon is out
It won't be Malzahn, our AD has already said HC experience at college or pro is a must. They went coordinator two hires in a row, they won't a third time.
Shalala would never sign off on Rich Rod. He has too many skeletons, and after all the emphasis they've put on grades, graduation rates and staying out of trouble, it will be a coach with a clean nose.
Gruden is not happening. Bielema does have a good situation but won't win huge there. I imagine he parlay's the interest into a $2.5 mil extension. I haven't seen any interest in Mullen, but he'd my guy after the top guys. After him I'd kick the tires on Randy Edsall...I don't think Cristobal is a serious candidate, but enough people say no, he could become one.
My early money is still on an underwhelming hire in Mike Stoops.
Shalala would never sign off on Rich Rod. He has too many skeletons, and after all the emphasis they've put on grades, graduation rates and staying out of trouble, it will be a coach with a clean nose.
Gruden is not happening. Bielema does have a good situation but won't win huge there. I imagine he parlay's the interest into a $2.5 mil extension. I haven't seen any interest in Mullen, but he'd my guy after the top guys. After him I'd kick the tires on Randy Edsall...I don't think Cristobal is a serious candidate, but enough people say no, he could become one.
My early money is still on an underwhelming hire in Mike Stoops.
- JunkBondTrader
- Veteran Player
- Posts: 547
- Joined: June 11 09, 1:46 am
-
phins
- Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
- Posts: 12085
- Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm
Re: Randy Shannon is out
I have a verifiable email to a group of people that Al Golden was my #1 target of the "obtainable" guys all along. Meaning, no Patterson, Peterson, Harbaugh (or Gruden).
Temple was 1-22 in the two years before he got there. They were the worst team in college football, without a doubt. He took that team, and turned that culture around completely. With zero athletes, and no tradition, he turned them into a 8 and 9 win program. He's known as a top notch recruiter. He comes from the Bill Parcells coaching tree. He was a player at Penn State. He's young. He's energetic. He has no ties to Miami, something I wanted after what I feel like is too long looking at the past and trying to hold onto that NFL U moniker. His teams have always been known for being tough and disciplined. He's a defensive coach, first and foremost.
He played offense as a TE, and then became a top notch defensive coach. He was the youngest DC in the country when he was hired at Virginia, so he knows the ACC, and had success. He is one of the few coaches with ties to both sides of the ball, something a HC can really use to his advantage, even moreso than a coordinator can (having played offense, but coached defense).
Golden has experience at a college in a major metropolitan area, that isn't the only game in town, a stadium that is off campus and hard to field, and used to not being the only draw in town. He used the things the area does have to his advantage though, and recruited effectively BECAUSE of it, rather than in SPITE of it. He runs a different scheme on defense than Miami has run since 1979 when Howard Schellenberger took over. He has experience as a HC, and showed it wasn't too big for him.
I say this with all sincerity, and not in hindsight, but I like this hire more than Florida's hire, which surprises me since Florida is a better job. Now I just hope he doesn't jump to Penn State when Joe Pa finally retires.
Temple was 1-22 in the two years before he got there. They were the worst team in college football, without a doubt. He took that team, and turned that culture around completely. With zero athletes, and no tradition, he turned them into a 8 and 9 win program. He's known as a top notch recruiter. He comes from the Bill Parcells coaching tree. He was a player at Penn State. He's young. He's energetic. He has no ties to Miami, something I wanted after what I feel like is too long looking at the past and trying to hold onto that NFL U moniker. His teams have always been known for being tough and disciplined. He's a defensive coach, first and foremost.
He played offense as a TE, and then became a top notch defensive coach. He was the youngest DC in the country when he was hired at Virginia, so he knows the ACC, and had success. He is one of the few coaches with ties to both sides of the ball, something a HC can really use to his advantage, even moreso than a coordinator can (having played offense, but coached defense).
Golden has experience at a college in a major metropolitan area, that isn't the only game in town, a stadium that is off campus and hard to field, and used to not being the only draw in town. He used the things the area does have to his advantage though, and recruited effectively BECAUSE of it, rather than in SPITE of it. He runs a different scheme on defense than Miami has run since 1979 when Howard Schellenberger took over. He has experience as a HC, and showed it wasn't too big for him.
I say this with all sincerity, and not in hindsight, but I like this hire more than Florida's hire, which surprises me since Florida is a better job. Now I just hope he doesn't jump to Penn State when Joe Pa finally retires.
- clevername
- Bringer of FRBG
- Posts: 10380
- Joined: April 16 06, 7:13 pm
- Location: Alabama
Re: Randy Shannon is out
I'm interested to see how his personality meshes with the current (and past) environment down there.
I think they could have done much worse, especially with that Trestman talk. I think he'll be solid, but it won't be a quick turnaround. If given time he'll get them consistently back at the top of their division with Va Tech.
An interesting stat I saw earlier: he's won 26 games in his career and only 2 of those were against teams that went on to have a winning record that year (Navy '09 and UConn this year).
I think they could have done much worse, especially with that Trestman talk. I think he'll be solid, but it won't be a quick turnaround. If given time he'll get them consistently back at the top of their division with Va Tech.
An interesting stat I saw earlier: he's won 26 games in his career and only 2 of those were against teams that went on to have a winning record that year (Navy '09 and UConn this year).



