I had a javascript class where the finals were writing a script and it was Pass/Fail. The only tool we had to write the javascript was our notes and notepad, no validators or anything, AND it was timed.
And it's not like we were experienced in Javascript, this was our first class with the scripting language. So we had two hours to write a javascript (the first test was validating a 10 field form ((had SSN, email, phone) script in notepad without any tools and have it run without any errors using Internet Explorer (no developer toolbar) and Notepad.
60% of the class failed because of random bugs we wouldn't find. I rewrote my script from scratch three times and ended up failing because I didn't put a semi-colin at the end of one line. And the 40% that did pass, half of them were people who cheated and sent eachother the same code.
I talked to the guy repeatedly about how you can't teach a programming language like that pass/fail beacuse we're not experts in the field, he tried to argue that you couldn't keep a job if you couldn't get your code to work. We ended up having to go to the college board and complain about the teacher. He ended up being fired.
I thought it was totally stupid then, now that I use javascript daily in a work environment I think his methods are absolutely ridiculous.
Rant: Over complicating things
- TheoSqua
- Next Gen Wart
- Posts: 8951
- Joined: April 22 06, 6:53 pm
- Location: St. Louis
- Contact:
-
Arthur Dent
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12542
- Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
- Location: Austin
Re: Rant: Over complicating things
Gotta do the things that keep you interested. The bottom line can be pretty boring.TheoSqua wrote:I think programmers just like to use the skills they have.
- vinsanity
- Chili dog truther
- Posts: 8836
- Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
- Location: Indianapolis
Re: Rant: Over complicating things
Sometimes I understand this, but in my first C class we weren't allowed to use any string libraries. We had to iterate char *'s for every damn project.TheoSqua wrote:So we had two hours to write a javascript (the first test was validating a 10 field form ((had SSN, email, phone) script in notepad without any tools and have it run without any errors using Internet Explorer (no developer toolbar) and Notepad.
You get fired for re-inventing the wheel every time. So to test on it is kind of stupid.
- cards2468
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 14745
- Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
- Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT
Re: Rant: Over complicating things
my class was like this. our final was over 2 different languages and we had to write on paper the code we'd put into the computer given a problem stated on the test. essentially had to write around 100 lines of code in an hour. Half in C+, the other half in Matlab.TheoSqua wrote:I had a javascript class where the finals were writing a script and it was Pass/Fail. The only tool we had to write the javascript was our notes and notepad, no validators or anything, AND it was timed.
And it's not like we were experienced in Javascript, this was our first class with the scripting language. So we had two hours to write a javascript (the first test was validating a 10 field form ((had SSN, email, phone) script in notepad without any tools and have it run without any errors using Internet Explorer (no developer toolbar) and Notepad.
60% of the class failed because of random bugs we wouldn't find. I rewrote my script from scratch three times and ended up failing because I didn't put a semi-colin at the end of one line. And the 40% that did pass, half of them were people who cheated and sent eachother the same code.
I talked to the guy repeatedly about how you can't teach a programming language like that pass/fail beacuse we're not experts in the field, he tried to argue that you couldn't keep a job if you couldn't get your code to work. We ended up having to go to the college board and complain about the teacher. He ended up being fired.
I thought it was totally stupid then, now that I use javascript daily in a work environment I think his methods are absolutely ridiculous.
-
jim
- Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
- Posts: 50393
- Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm
Re: Rant: Over complicating things
What you described are the opposite of skills.TheoSqua wrote:I think programmers just like to use the skills they have.
Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication ~ Leonardo da Vinci.
- Bo Hart
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 8770
- Joined: April 14 06, 9:50 pm
Re: Rant: Over complicating things
WOW.TheoSqua wrote:I thought it was totally stupid then, now that I use javascript daily in a work environment I think his methods are absolutely ridiculous.
First of all, JavaScript is just inherently fragile. If one thing breaks, it basically breaks everything. Second of all, Internet Explorer blows, and it's especially anal when it comes to it's interpretation of JavaScript. Those two things mixed together sounds like a deadly combination.

