Update: Health Care Reform

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by vinsanity »

TimeForGuinness wrote:I'm all for having a lower capital gains tax to stoke the investment fire...but you could increase the capital gains rate while making it lower than the Income Tax, and they're still winning (if they win) against the Income Tax...
Well, shouldn't they also be willing to a pay a higher % if they were making more money in a healthy economy?

We had unprecedented growth on the late 90's with rates higher than the last 10 years. If tax cuts on capital gains and personal income stimulate the economy, how come the 6 or 7 years leading up to the crash were shaky, unsteady gains?

The economy can't recover with these deficits, and taxes at least need to be at Pre-Bush levels to help cut them.

User avatar
JackofDiamonds
Bringer of Boston Baked Blue Balls
Posts: 15010
Joined: April 16 06, 9:15 pm

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by JackofDiamonds »

Flattaxforlife.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by Arthur Dent »

ghostrunner wrote:Maybe the accountants can weigh in - is there ever a case where going up to a higher tax bracket truly costs you money? My dad once told me (think i was in college) that was essentially rubbish, though that was a long time ago.
Your dad is correct. That's why they are called marginal tax rates. A simple example:

Suppose the tax brackets are the following:
$0 - $10,000: 10%
>$10,000: 20%

In that case if you make less that $10k, you pay 10% tax. If you make more than $10k, you pay 10% tax on the first $10k ($1k), and 20% tax on income greater than $20k. If you made $20k, for example, your tax would be $3k = $10k*0.1+($20k-$10k)*0.2. That's an effective tax rate of 15% not 20%.

This is why "keeping the middle class tax cuts" where middle class is defined as those earning less than $250k is actually, in large part, keeping tax cuts for the wealthy. Most people in the middle class make way less that $250k, but everyone who makes more benefits from lower tax on that first $250k.
vinsanity wrote:The economy can't recover with these deficits
Why? The usual argument on how government deficits hurt the economy is by soaking up investment money and driving up interest rates. But interest rates are extremely low. People are clamoring to give the US government more money. We should be taking advantage of this. There are plenty of worthwhile uses that would simultaneously get people employed again.

But I think many people view deficits in moral terms. Too much borrowing is unseemly and wrong, and can only bring punishment down upon you.
TimeForGuinness wrote:I'm all for having a lower capital gains tax to stoke the investment fire
But there's scant evidence that this does anything worthwhile. People invest when they have the money and think they can make a profit on it. Low investment taxes are primarily about transferring money to the already wealthy. The supposed economic benefits are mostly just a more palatable pretext.
JackofDiamonds wrote:I don't agree with the sentiment, but one of our clients was viscerally angry about it, because as she sees it, she's losing the incentive to invest in private equity/venture capital for small firms. She has the intermittent big wins, but more often than not it's a 100k-500k loss. She can write the losses off against the gains, but then she's penalized for being successful. If private wealth is the engine of growth, do we want to discourage individual investors from taking the risks by muting the reward?
That argument doesn't make any sense at all unless you view all tax as punishment. Risky investments has got nothing to do with anything if you're taxed on the net.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31094
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by Popeye_Card »

Arthur Dent wrote:
But I think many people view deficits in moral terms. Too much borrowing is unseemly and wrong, and can only bring punishment down upon you.
I can understand why borrowing by itself is not the worst idea. But borrowing money from China just to spend like drunken sailors does not seem like a wise plan for the long-term health of a country's economy.

That said, I don't think that healthcare is something silly to spend money on, even though the recent health care reform bill is a bit of good sprinkled in with a bunch of garbage (IMO). I think it's worthy of spending money on, if the plan is right. Just like Social Security isn't a bad idea, just currently very poorly constructed. Just like defense spending isn't a bad idea, just currently very poorly executed. See a trend?

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by Arthur Dent »

Popeye_Card wrote:I'm sure snopes is on the case, but I am guessing that as usual, while not being flat-out lies, the majority of those claims are either misunderstandings of the actual laws, or greatly exaggerating their effects.

I did like how many hot button words and topics they mixed in. Obamacare. Special needs children. Death tax. Education. I love these emails.
What find particularly galling about these breathless panics about the income tax is that it is not at all difficult to see how much tax you are paying. It's right there on the bottom of your tax form. But instead relying on the easily accessible facts, people's impressions on how much tax they are paying seem to be largely determined by political prejudices about whomever the President happens to be. They KNOW that Obama jacked up their taxes because that's what them tax `n spend libruls do. Except they don't.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31094
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by Popeye_Card »

Arthur Dent wrote:
Popeye_Card wrote:I'm sure snopes is on the case, but I am guessing that as usual, while not being flat-out lies, the majority of those claims are either misunderstandings of the actual laws, or greatly exaggerating their effects.

I did like how many hot button words and topics they mixed in. Obamacare. Special needs children. Death tax. Education. I love these emails.
What find particularly galling about these breathless panics about the income tax is that it is not at all difficult to see how much tax you are paying. It's right there on the bottom of your tax form. But instead relying on the easily accessible facts, people's impressions on how much tax they are paying seem to be largely determined by political prejudices about whomever the President happens to be. They KNOW that Obama jacked up their taxes because that's what them tax `n spend libruls do. Except they don't.
I think "hidden taxes" freak them out.

It usually isn't a case of extra money being taken away from them, but more about not taking advantage of loopholes. That's the thing that bugs me most about taxes in this country. It isn't what we pay. It's all the freaking loopholes to get out of paying, most of them ultimately benefiting the already rich. Each of them is promoted to promote investment in this or that, but I think it's high time to nip these things in the bud and go back to a much simplified income tax system.

EDIT: Didn't mean to imply that all sorts of hidden taxes exist. Meant to suggest that they're freaked out about hidden taxes that either don't exist, or don't possibly apply to them.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by Arthur Dent »

Popeye_Card wrote:But borrowing money from China just to spend like drunken sailors does not seem like a wise plan for the long-term health of a country's economy.

That said, I don't think that healthcare is something silly to spend money on, even though the recent health care reform bill is a bit of good sprinkled in with a bunch of garbage (IMO). I think it's worthy of spending money on, if the plan is right. Just like Social Security isn't a bad idea, just currently very poorly constructed. Just like defense spending isn't a bad idea, just currently very poorly executed. See a trend?
These narratives, "borrowing money from China to spend like a drunken sailor," don't have much correspondence with reality. What exactly is this drunken sailor spending? Is it the Bush tax cuts? The wars? The choice not to massively contract spending after an economic crash? I don't think that's what people using this line have in mind. They're thinking of bridges to nowhere and giant rooms full of administrators administering other administrators. But these things are not driving the deficit. That narrative is invented so people can feel righteous is demanding tax cuts that can be implemented without cost. The fact that China buys US debt seems to be largely immaterial. This is driven mostly by the Chinese government's efforts to support their exports by keeping a low currency value. The big debt issues today have been purchased mostly by Americans.

Of course, plenty of tax money is spent in ways that I would not desire, but this is hardly unique to taxes.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31094
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by Popeye_Card »

Arthur Dent wrote:
Popeye_Card wrote:But borrowing money from China just to spend like drunken sailors does not seem like a wise plan for the long-term health of a country's economy.

That said, I don't think that healthcare is something silly to spend money on, even though the recent health care reform bill is a bit of good sprinkled in with a bunch of garbage (IMO). I think it's worthy of spending money on, if the plan is right. Just like Social Security isn't a bad idea, just currently very poorly constructed. Just like defense spending isn't a bad idea, just currently very poorly executed. See a trend?
These narratives, "borrowing money from China to spend like a drunken sailor," don't have much correspondence with reality. What exactly is this drunken sailor spending? Is it the Bush tax cuts? The wars? The choice not to massively contract spending after an economic crash? I don't think that's what people using this line have in mind. They're thinking of bridges to nowhere and giant rooms full of administrators administering other administrators. But these things are not driving the deficit. That narrative is invented so people can feel righteous is demanding tax cuts that can be implemented without cost. The fact that China buys US debt seems to be largely immaterial. This is driven mostly by the Chinese government's efforts to support their exports by keeping a low currency value. The big debt issues today have been purchased mostly by Americans.

Of course, plenty of tax money is spent in ways that I would not desire, but this is hardly unique to taxes.
In general, I am a proponent of government spending--even "wasteful" spending--because it does act as a driver to the economy, and any money spent does usually find it's way back to the government through taxes on every transaction.

But the current spending structure is jacked up. Too much money spent in certain sectors isolates/slows total impact on the economy. Spending money on wars gives very modest return back to the domestic economy compared to money completely spent within the system. In addition, states shouldn't be struggling as much as they are to fund critical programs such as education and road repairs. Some of that (a lot? all?) is mismanagement of funds over the years.

I know I should beef up more on macroeconomics before making such statements. But I do feel that the federal (and state) budgets are very much less than ideal, and when you pull politics into the mix, it only makes the bad parts of it worse.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by Arthur Dent »

Popeye_Card wrote:That's the thing that bugs me most about taxes in this country. It isn't what we pay. It's all the freaking loopholes to get out of paying, most of them ultimately benefiting the already rich.
Yup.

Image

But the narrative is completely backwards. People perceive the system as inherently unfair, and it is, but not for the reasons people think.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31094
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: Update: Health Care Reform

Post by Popeye_Card »

Arthur Dent wrote:
Popeye_Card wrote:That's the thing that bugs me most about taxes in this country. It isn't what we pay. It's all the freaking loopholes to get out of paying, most of them ultimately benefiting the already rich.
Yup.

Image

But the narrative is completely backwards. People perceive the system as inherently unfair, and it is, but not for the reasons people think.
Wasn't the rate under that socialist distribitor of wealth Nixon above 50%?

Post Reply