Wow. I pretty much agree with all of that.BW23 wrote:My problem, and it's more of a local problem than one with counseling in general, at the secondary level is the push for "college". By college I mean the traditional four-year university. Locally, approximately 35% go to a four-year school after graduation. Yet, that's what the focus is on. Constantly. Getting kids ready for "college". Don't get me wrong, I think postsecondary education is vital, but we're failing 65% of our students if we're only focusing on the ones that will go on to college. Not only that, but we're failing our community as the 35% leave the rural community for greener pastures and rarely come back.phinstd wrote:What exactly is the problem you see with counselors? I get it from her perspective, so I'd like to hear what someone else thinks.
She taught third grade at a private school for three years while she finished her Master's in counseling, so she has that perspective as well.
It needs to be more career counseling.
And the counseling needs to be more towards career prep in an area of interest (done by interest inventory, not asking the kids what they want to take).
That's my short answer.
Being unemployed
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: Being unemployed
- BW23
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12896
- Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm
Re: Being unemployed
I figured she was elementary if she was the only one in a big school. That's pretty common, unfortunately.
I do disagree about pushing kids to "college" in the sense I mentioned earlier. I do think, as I said, that postsecondary education is crucial. I think it's almost to the point where some type of advanced education beyond high school is required for anything above minimum wage jobs. As you stated, a skill to fall back on....well, I think the skill is more important than the degree. Most employers would likely agree.
Only about 28-33% of jobs require a 4-year degree. That won't change significantly. (I haven't seen the numbers over the last couple of years, but I'm sure that's about right as of today as well.) Technical training of some type is essential if kids aren't getting a four-year degree. Many kids that take advantage of career and technical offerings and/or A+ programs can obtain an associate's degree after a semester or two after HS graduation. Obviously, that opens the door for immediate or future articulation with a four-year school.
There was a time not that long ago where Missouri had many high-skill job openings that were going unfilled because of a lack of qualified applicants. I'm talking tens of thousands of jobs. There weren't enough taking advantage of the right schools and programs in the state.
I'm not sure how to fix this, but I'm trying on my end.
I do disagree about pushing kids to "college" in the sense I mentioned earlier. I do think, as I said, that postsecondary education is crucial. I think it's almost to the point where some type of advanced education beyond high school is required for anything above minimum wage jobs. As you stated, a skill to fall back on....well, I think the skill is more important than the degree. Most employers would likely agree.
Only about 28-33% of jobs require a 4-year degree. That won't change significantly. (I haven't seen the numbers over the last couple of years, but I'm sure that's about right as of today as well.) Technical training of some type is essential if kids aren't getting a four-year degree. Many kids that take advantage of career and technical offerings and/or A+ programs can obtain an associate's degree after a semester or two after HS graduation. Obviously, that opens the door for immediate or future articulation with a four-year school.
There was a time not that long ago where Missouri had many high-skill job openings that were going unfilled because of a lack of qualified applicants. I'm talking tens of thousands of jobs. There weren't enough taking advantage of the right schools and programs in the state.
I'm not sure how to fix this, but I'm trying on my end.
- BW23
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12896
- Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm
Re: Being unemployed
lukethedrifter wrote:Miracles do happen!BW23 wrote:My problem, and it's more of a local problem than one with counseling in general, at the secondary level is the push for "college". By college I mean the traditional four-year university. Locally, approximately 35% go to a four-year school after graduation. Yet, that's what the focus is on. Constantly. Getting kids ready for "college". Don't get me wrong, I think postsecondary education is vital, but we're failing 65% of our students if we're only focusing on the ones that will go on to college. Not only that, but we're failing our community as the 35% leave the rural community for greener pastures and rarely come back.phinstd wrote:What exactly is the problem you see with counselors? I get it from her perspective, so I'd like to hear what someone else thinks.
She taught third grade at a private school for three years while she finished her Master's in counseling, so she has that perspective as well.
It needs to be more career counseling.
And the counseling needs to be more towards career prep in an area of interest (done by interest inventory, not asking the kids what they want to take).
That's my short answer.
Wow. I pretty much agree with all of that.
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30873
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: Being unemployed
As of a couple weeks ago, my wife suddenly has 3 possibilities all at once.
The most likely one has involved the following for her:
Phone interview
2nd Phone interview a week later.
An in person interview with two different departments, which took about 3 hours.
An online "Caliper Assessment" test, which had ethical questions, IQ type questions where she had to identify patterns, and personality questions
Two weeks later, a series of 3 interviews on the same day. That was yesterday and I had to take off work so I could stay home with the newborn while she did it.
All this so she can tell a few graphic designers what to do. I told her "don't hold back on the salary request with these freaks."
The most likely one has involved the following for her:
Phone interview
2nd Phone interview a week later.
An in person interview with two different departments, which took about 3 hours.
An online "Caliper Assessment" test, which had ethical questions, IQ type questions where she had to identify patterns, and personality questions
Two weeks later, a series of 3 interviews on the same day. That was yesterday and I had to take off work so I could stay home with the newborn while she did it.
All this so she can tell a few graphic designers what to do. I told her "don't hold back on the salary request with these freaks."
- BW23
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12896
- Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm
Re: Being unemployed
I would suspect, and may be wrong, that more companies will be going to greater lengths with more quality on the job market now.ghostrunner wrote:As of a couple weeks ago, my wife suddenly has 3 possibilities all at once.
The most likely one has involved the following for her:
Phone interview
2nd Phone interview a week later.
An in person interview with two different departments, which took about 3 hours.
An online "Caliper Assessment" test, which had ethical questions, IQ type questions where she had to identify patterns, and personality questions
Two weeks later, a series of 3 interviews on the same day. That was yesterday and I had to take off work so I could stay home with the newborn while she did it.
All this so she can tell a few graphic designers what to do. I told her "don't hold back on the salary request with these freaks."
-
planet planet
- http://tinyurl.com/2e4x5hy
- Posts: 24904
- Joined: April 15 06, 6:25 pm
- Location: St. Louis
Re: Being unemployed
Agreed. I'm going through a described 24 hr. process myself. It's borderline sadistic.BW23 wrote:I would suspect, and may be wrong, that more companies will be going to greater lengths with more quality on the job market now.ghostrunner wrote:As of a couple weeks ago, my wife suddenly has 3 possibilities all at once.
The most likely one has involved the following for her:
Phone interview
2nd Phone interview a week later.
An in person interview with two different departments, which took about 3 hours.
An online "Caliper Assessment" test, which had ethical questions, IQ type questions where she had to identify patterns, and personality questions
Two weeks later, a series of 3 interviews on the same day. That was yesterday and I had to take off work so I could stay home with the newborn while she did it.
All this so she can tell a few graphic designers what to do. I told her "don't hold back on the salary request with these freaks."
-
phins
- Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
- Posts: 12085
- Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm
Re: Being unemployed
Since you seem to know the numbers, or have access to them, I won't argue those, since I don't know them. You make a great point about skilled jobs, as having a "skill" will almost always have a job ready for you. While if you merely have an education, it doesn't separate you on a "skills" level from the other people with ordinary educations (by that, I mean not an Ivy League etc).BW23 wrote:I figured she was elementary if she was the only one in a big school. That's pretty common, unfortunately.
I do disagree about pushing kids to "college" in the sense I mentioned earlier. I do think, as I said, that postsecondary education is crucial. I think it's almost to the point where some type of advanced education beyond high school is required for anything above minimum wage jobs. As you stated, a skill to fall back on....well, I think the skill is more important than the degree. Most employers would likely agree.
Only about 28-33% of jobs require a 4-year degree. That won't change significantly. (I haven't seen the numbers over the last couple of years, but I'm sure that's about right as of today as well.) Technical training of some type is essential if kids aren't getting a four-year degree. Many kids that take advantage of career and technical offerings and/or A+ programs can obtain an associate's degree after a semester or two after HS graduation. Obviously, that opens the door for immediate or future articulation with a four-year school.
There was a time not that long ago where Missouri had many high-skill job openings that were going unfilled because of a lack of qualified applicants. I'm talking tens of thousands of jobs. There weren't enough taking advantage of the right schools and programs in the state.
I'm not sure how to fix this, but I'm trying on my end.
I'm finding out firsthand, as my MBA seems to have opened zero doors that weren't open before.
-
Freed Roger
- Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
- Posts: 26073
- Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
- Location: St. Louis
Re: Being unemployed
lordy, what is a 24 hr process?planet pujolsian wrote:Agreed. I'm going through a described 24 hr. process myself. It's borderline sadistic.BW23 wrote:I would suspect, and may be wrong, that more companies will be going to greater lengths with more quality on the job market now.ghostrunner wrote:As of a couple weeks ago, my wife suddenly has 3 possibilities all at once.
The most likely one has involved the following for her:
Phone interview
2nd Phone interview a week later.
An in person interview with two different departments, which took about 3 hours.
An online "Caliper Assessment" test, which had ethical questions, IQ type questions where she had to identify patterns, and personality questions
Two weeks later, a series of 3 interviews on the same day. That was yesterday and I had to take off work so I could stay home with the newborn while she did it.
All this so she can tell a few graphic designers what to do. I told her "don't hold back on the salary request with these freaks."
Extensive interview processes are ok i guess, but I wonder how much of it is just for show rather merit-based. all that hullabaloo- is it CYA for the company, and/or job security for the personnel dept -, and then they give the job to the person with the In.
- JCShutout
- MacGyver of Underwear
- Posts: 13368
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:53 am
- Location: South City
Re: Being unemployed
I haven't really followed this thread, but I peaked in, read this and also agreed pretty much with all of that.lukethedrifter wrote:Wow. I pretty much agree with all of that.BW23 wrote:My problem, and it's more of a local problem than one with counseling in general, at the secondary level is the push for "college". By college I mean the traditional four-year university. Locally, approximately 35% go to a four-year school after graduation. Yet, that's what the focus is on. Constantly. Getting kids ready for "college". Don't get me wrong, I think postsecondary education is vital, but we're failing 65% of our students if we're only focusing on the ones that will go on to college. Not only that, but we're failing our community as the 35% leave the rural community for greener pastures and rarely come back.phinstd wrote:What exactly is the problem you see with counselors? I get it from her perspective, so I'd like to hear what someone else thinks.
She taught third grade at a private school for three years while she finished her Master's in counseling, so she has that perspective as well.
It needs to be more career counseling.
And the counseling needs to be more towards career prep in an area of interest (done by interest inventory, not asking the kids what they want to take).
That's my short answer.
- BW23
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12896
- Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm
Re: Being unemployed
I think they have a sleep study as part of it. They don't want to hire anyone that might have sleep apnea. They probably want to see if he gets a healthy amount of hours and deep sleep.Freed Roger wrote:lordy, what is a 24 hr process?planet pujolsian wrote:Agreed. I'm going through a described 24 hr. process myself. It's borderline sadistic.BW23 wrote:I would suspect, and may be wrong, that more companies will be going to greater lengths with more quality on the job market now.ghostrunner wrote:As of a couple weeks ago, my wife suddenly has 3 possibilities all at once.
The most likely one has involved the following for her:
Phone interview
2nd Phone interview a week later.
An in person interview with two different departments, which took about 3 hours.
An online "Caliper Assessment" test, which had ethical questions, IQ type questions where she had to identify patterns, and personality questions
Two weeks later, a series of 3 interviews on the same day. That was yesterday and I had to take off work so I could stay home with the newborn while she did it.
All this so she can tell a few graphic designers what to do. I told her "don't hold back on the salary request with these freaks."
Extensive interview processes are ok i guess, but I wonder how much of it is just for show rather merit-based. all that hullabaloo- is it CYA for the company, and/or job security for the personnel dept -, and then they give the job to the person with the In.


