Rave: High School Football

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by jim »

I will say that the comments about the private schools not all playing that game is true. I've seen some really bad HS catholic school teams, but of course nobody focuses on those and only looks at the big name schools.

If you are a catholic school and every year you are in the hunt for a state championship, shame on you.

User avatar
Sutter'sBeard
is the oscar meyer weiner kid
Posts: 3140
Joined: July 25 06, 1:02 pm
Location: Decatur, IL

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by Sutter'sBeard »

jim wrote:I will say that the comments about the private schools not all playing that game is true. I've seen some really bad HS catholic school teams, but of course nobody focuses on those and only looks at the big name schools.

If you are a catholic school and every year you are in the hunt for a state championship, shame on you.

I haven't. Decatur St. Teresa, Bloomington Central Catholic, Springfield SHG, Joliet CC, MT. Carmel, etc have had the sum total of about two losing seasons combined in the last 30 years. There is just now way that they do not have an advantage. I really don't think they do all that much recruiting as many speculate. They just start with a little better gene pool than most public schools. They have parents that are more involved in their kids education (ie-they pay great sums to make sure they get a good education).

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by Freed Roger »

Sutter'sBeard wrote:
jim wrote:I will say that the comments about the private schools not all playing that game is true. I've seen some really bad HS catholic school teams, but of course nobody focuses on those and only looks at the big name schools.

If you are a catholic school and every year you are in the hunt for a state championship, shame on you.

I haven't. Decatur St. Teresa, Bloomington Central Catholic, Springfield SHG, Joliet CC, MT. Carmel, etc have had the sum total of about two losing seasons combined in the last 30 years. There is just now way that they do not have an advantage. I really don't think they do all that much recruiting as many speculate. They just start with a little better gene pool than most public schools. They have parents that are more involved in their kids education (ie-they pay great sums to make sure they get a good education).
But the schools you mention, and ones like Breese Mater Dei or QND, their success can hardly be attributable to recruiting
Its more about the factors you mention . The Catholic families tend to have larger clans, and the kids grow up in sports aspiring for the day they play for the HS team their brother or uncle played at. Its a legacy.

Well times are a changin- with the economy of today, look for declining enrollment in private schools. Kids interested in playing for winning schools may not want to go to the small stage. Maybe they will have to put a multiplier on public schools ten years from now -gotta punish success.

Without a doubt, there aren't as many black Catholics as show up on some HS teams. But if people in those schools get a charge off winning that way then bully for them.

User avatar
Radio_Bugtussle
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 3450
Joined: July 26 06, 9:51 am
Location: Searching for the perfect microbrew

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by Radio_Bugtussle »

Freed Roger wrote: Its more about the factors you mention . The Catholic families tend to have larger clans, and the kids grow up in sports aspiring for the day they play for the HS team their brother or uncle played at. Its a legacy.
.
I'm very familiar with the QND program. Their work ethic is what separates them from the pack. But that's also what separates winning public school athletic programs from the losers/whiners.

User avatar
BW23
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12896
Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by BW23 »

I'm going to continue to be a whiner, then...because that's who that comment was for. The only thing this is teaching KIDS about the real world is that if you have enough money or prestige, you can win. Work ethic has nothing to do with it.

Allow open enrollment and I can pull kids from a smaller radius right now than any single private school in the state pulls from and beat any school in the state. Easily.

Not fair? Neither is the real world. (Yeah, the real world argument is stupid when anyone uses it.)

User avatar
BW23
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12896
Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by BW23 »

Freed Roger wrote:
Sutter'sBeard wrote:
jim wrote:I will say that the comments about the private schools not all playing that game is true. I've seen some really bad HS catholic school teams, but of course nobody focuses on those and only looks at the big name schools.

If you are a catholic school and every year you are in the hunt for a state championship, shame on you.

I haven't. Decatur St. Teresa, Bloomington Central Catholic, Springfield SHG, Joliet CC, MT. Carmel, etc have had the sum total of about two losing seasons combined in the last 30 years. There is just now way that they do not have an advantage. I really don't think they do all that much recruiting as many speculate. They just start with a little better gene pool than most public schools. They have parents that are more involved in their kids education (ie-they pay great sums to make sure they get a good education).
But the schools you mention, and ones like Breese Mater Dei or QND, their success can hardly be attributable to recruiting
Its more about the factors you mention . The Catholic families tend to have larger clans, and the kids grow up in sports aspiring for the day they play for the HS team their brother or uncle played at. Its a legacy.

Well times are a changin- with the economy of today, look for declining enrollment in private schools. Kids interested in playing for winning schools may not want to go to the small stage. Maybe they will have to put a multiplier on public schools ten years from now -gotta punish success.

Without a doubt, there aren't as many black Catholics as show up on some HS teams. But if people in those schools get a charge off winning that way then bully for them.
If the schools that put such an emphasis on winning see a decline in enrollment, they'll just continue to offer "scholarships" to kids. Then again, they're already doing that. I know plenty of first team all staters that have had these offers after heavy recruiting. I know others that are non-stars but great overall athletes with these offers. I know a local "father" that runs a private school that recruits 10 year olds. The school heavily recruits 8th graders to get them in before the kids' frosh year so that they don't lose a year of eligibility if they were to enroll in HS without moving.

Now, if you would allow my local school to waive their ADA on kids that live out of district (which means the school wouldn't collect any monies on students out of district) therefore allowing the school to not charge tuition, we can talk.

User avatar
BW23
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12896
Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by BW23 »

Freed Roger wrote:The irony. Penalizing schools that are successful in sports. Making the playing field level and "Fair" for everyone.

Thats not how the real world rolls.
How is creating a separate playoff system for private schools penalizing? Claiming that is penalizing is ridiculous. If the playing field shouldn't be level, then lets get rid of all rules. Or is there some need to keep some rules? The real world doesn't really work by many rules. What other rules should we get rid of? I'd really love to know.

M1IRONMIKE
Well hello, pilgrim
Posts: 4129
Joined: October 7 06, 7:23 am
Location: springfield illinois

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by M1IRONMIKE »

Let me clarify my complaint with these schools. I have no problem with parents taking advantage of whatever inducements given to them to get their kids in these schools. I have no problem with these schools being foootball powerhouses. My problems lies with the fact that these schools hand out the need based aid for these students (in our local case football players) to come to the school and in a lot of cases a tremendously large amount of aid and then these schools get to compete against public schools who are bound by the rules of boundaries and are subject to the IHSA slamming their asses if they go out an actively recruit students from outside the boundaries. The playing field is ridiculously uneven. The State playoff series needs to be separated by public schools and private schools. Lets these powerhouses play each other and let public schools who abide by the equal and fair set of rules play each other.

User avatar
Radio_Bugtussle
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 3450
Joined: July 26 06, 9:51 am
Location: Searching for the perfect microbrew

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by Radio_Bugtussle »

BW23 wrote:
Freed Roger wrote:The irony. Penalizing schools that are successful in sports. Making the playing field level and "Fair" for everyone.

Thats not how the real world rolls.
How is creating a separate playoff system for private schools penalizing? Claiming that is penalizing is ridiculous. If the playing field shouldn't be level, then lets get rid of all rules. Or is there some need to keep some rules? The real world doesn't really work by many rules. What other rules should we get rid of? I'd really love to know.

That would constitute fixing something that isn't broken. Wasted time and wasted effort.

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: Rave: High School Football

Post by lukethedrifter »

The public HS that I went to is going for its 4th State Championship in the last 30 years tomorrow. That's not too bad.


BW, you want a totally separate playoff system for private schools? This is Missouri not California or Texas. Why not just go to a Bowl system where every school gets to play and every kid gets a trophy?

Post Reply