Brett Favre.

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
jimedmondsfan
Veteran Player
Posts: 782
Joined: August 24 06, 11:38 am
Location: Out of my mind
Contact:

Re: Brett Favre.

Post by jimedmondsfan »

phinstd wrote:Emmitt Smith did not want to leave...the Cowboys ushered him out when he wasn't ready to quit.

Isaac Bruce: Same thing.

Joe Montana: Same thing.

Joe Namath: Same thing.

The difference? Brett Favre can still play, and play well. If he couldn't, guess what the Packers would do with him? Tell him to retire or be released.

Favre is wrong in the way he has waffled on his decision, but if the Packers really were forcing a decision he wasn't ready to make, I don't think he's completely to blame, and I don't think he's doing anything terribly wrong other than coming off as a baby to the media. Favre should be able to play as long as he wants to, and a team will have him, just like the other guys who lost their luster.

Again, my only problem with him in all of this is the flip-flopping he has done.
Then he should not have signed a 3 year extension in GB...he should have done a one year and been eligible for free agency so he could play elsewhere. The guy is 100 years old. He had to know they had a QB ready to step in and play. And at his age to balk at being a backup is kinda silly. IMO

User avatar
heyzeus
Everday Unicorn
Posts: 43335
Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
Location: Austin, TX

Re: Brett Favre.

Post by heyzeus »

The main thrust of my rant is that this ongoing saga is getting clubbed into my head every time I want to read about sports. Today Favre sent a text message about his itch. Today Favre said that stories about him wanting to play again are premature. Today Favre says the Packers aren't being nice to him. Today....etc, ad nauseum. Maybe I should just ignore sports news during the all star break. Then, tonight when (some) games resume, I can just go back to reading about actual games that were played.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Brett Favre.

Post by phins »

jimedmondsfan wrote:
phinstd wrote:Emmitt Smith did not want to leave...the Cowboys ushered him out when he wasn't ready to quit.

Isaac Bruce: Same thing.

Joe Montana: Same thing.

Joe Namath: Same thing.

The difference? Brett Favre can still play, and play well. If he couldn't, guess what the Packers would do with him? Tell him to retire or be released.

Favre is wrong in the way he has waffled on his decision, but if the Packers really were forcing a decision he wasn't ready to make, I don't think he's completely to blame, and I don't think he's doing anything terribly wrong other than coming off as a baby to the media. Favre should be able to play as long as he wants to, and a team will have him, just like the other guys who lost their luster.

Again, my only problem with him in all of this is the flip-flopping he has done.
Then he should not have signed a 3 year extension in GB...he should have done a one year and been eligible for free agency so he could play elsewhere. The guy is 100 years old. He had to know they had a QB ready to step in and play. And at his age to balk at being a backup is kinda silly. IMO
Favre never even said he wanted to be released until the Packers said they didn't want him back as a starter etc. Nothing wrong with with that IMO.

If I'm him, I say, "Let us compete for the starting job if you don't want to release me."

Players have very little power, and that contract hubabaloo means next to nothing in the NFL. Extensions are signed often times, just to reduce their salary cap number, or create extra room at the appearance of the player being one of the highest paid at his position. Agent wins, player saves face, team saves money.

In short, the contract deal gets no love from me, because NFL teams throw players way like garbage every single day when they have YEARS left on their contracts. "If they didn't want the player, they shouldn't have signed him to that deal", just doesn't work on the average fan, why should it also work against the player?

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21909
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Brett Favre.

Post by Socnorb11 »

phinstd wrote:
In short, the contract deal gets no love from me, because NFL teams throw players way like garbage every single day when they have YEARS left on their contracts. "If they didn't want the player, they shouldn't have signed him to that deal", just doesn't work on the average fan, why should it also work against the player?
Because that's the deal that the Players Union agreed to.

The bottom line is that Favre relinquished the right to call all the shots in this thing when he retired.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Brett Favre.

Post by phins »

Socnorb11 wrote:
phinstd wrote:
In short, the contract deal gets no love from me, because NFL teams throw players way like garbage every single day when they have YEARS left on their contracts. "If they didn't want the player, they shouldn't have signed him to that deal", just doesn't work on the average fan, why should it also work against the player?
Because that's the deal that the Players Union agreed to.

The bottom line is that Favre relinquished the right to call all the shots in this thing when he retired.
Obviously not. Favre owns this situation...

Yeah, the Players Union agreed to it, so now you don't care bit. The players rarely have leverage, and they SHOULD use it when they can. You're really coming off as bitter in this whole debate to me...

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21909
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Brett Favre.

Post by Socnorb11 »

phinstd wrote:
Socnorb11 wrote:
phinstd wrote:
In short, the contract deal gets no love from me, because NFL teams throw players way like garbage every single day when they have YEARS left on their contracts. "If they didn't want the player, they shouldn't have signed him to that deal", just doesn't work on the average fan, why should it also work against the player?
Because that's the deal that the Players Union agreed to.

The bottom line is that Favre relinquished the right to call all the shots in this thing when he retired.
Obviously not. Favre owns this situation...

Yeah, the Players Union agreed to it, so now you don't care bit. The players rarely have leverage, and they SHOULD use it when they can. You're really coming off as bitter in this whole debate to me...
Bitter about what? I'm just annoyed....... that's all.

I'm not sure what kind of leverage Favre has, really. They don't have to play him, they don't have to trade him, and they don't have to release him. Going on CNN and throwing stones at the Packer organization doesn't change any of that.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Brett Favre.

Post by phins »

Socnorb11 wrote:
phinstd wrote:
Socnorb11 wrote:
phinstd wrote:
In short, the contract deal gets no love from me, because NFL teams throw players way like garbage every single day when they have YEARS left on their contracts. "If they didn't want the player, they shouldn't have signed him to that deal", just doesn't work on the average fan, why should it also work against the player?
Because that's the deal that the Players Union agreed to.

The bottom line is that Favre relinquished the right to call all the shots in this thing when he retired.
Obviously not. Favre owns this situation...

Yeah, the Players Union agreed to it, so now you don't care bit. The players rarely have leverage, and they SHOULD use it when they can. You're really coming off as bitter in this whole debate to me...
Bitter about what? I'm just annoyed....... that's all.

I'm not sure what kind of leverage Favre has, really. They don't have to play him, they don't have to trade him, and they don't have to release him. Going on CNN and throwing stones at the Packer organization doesn't change any of that.
I meant maybe bitter as a Packer fan (I have no idea what allegiance you have in football).

In my experience of public relation work etc. going on those media outlets and throwing stones is a move that is forcing their hand. There is no way on God's green Earth that the Packers can sit Brett Favre this year. That would be catastrophic to their public relations. Remember, the Packers are a publicly owned entity, so their public image means even more than the average team.

We aren't talking about Koren Robinson here, we're talking about Brett Favre. The man who has restructured his contract three times to lower his cap number, allow the team to add more players etc. This is the man that has a foundation in the tiny town of Green Bay to help with breast cancer awareness, and helps with cancer stricken children. This is Brett Favre, the greatest Packer QB ever (including Bart Starr). This is a man that brings the casual fan to the game, and everyone has heard of.

Surely you jest if you think that doesn't bring some level of leverage for Brett Favre. The Packers will ultimately have two options if they want to save face for the general public (provided they don't plan on doing the smart thing, and just play him). They can either trade him (the smart thing), or they can release him.

There is zero chance of him retiring again, and there is zero chance of them letting him sit as the backup QB this year. That would cost jobs, and tarnish legacies.

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21909
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Brett Favre.

Post by Socnorb11 »

The legacy is already tarnished, in my opinion.

I'm not a Packer fan.

Honestly, I don't care what the Packers & Favre end up doing. I just wish he'd stop flip-flopping, and stop throwing the organization under the bus on CNN every night.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Brett Favre.

Post by phins »

Socnorb11 wrote:The legacy is already tarnished, in my opinion.

I'm not a Packer fan.

Honestly, I don't care what the Packers & Favre end up doing. I just wish he'd stop flip-flopping, and stop throwing the organization under the bus on CNN every night.
The legacy isn't about Favre. His legacy pretty much cannot be tarnished IMO.

It wasn't tarnished for Fran Tarkenton, Joe Montana, Emmitt Smith, Joe Namath, and on and on.

Ten years from now, all people will remember is that the Packers released or traded Brett Favre, and whomever did it will be villified.

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21909
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Brett Favre.

Post by Socnorb11 »

phinstd wrote:
Socnorb11 wrote:The legacy is already tarnished, in my opinion.

I'm not a Packer fan.

Honestly, I don't care what the Packers & Favre end up doing. I just wish he'd stop flip-flopping, and stop throwing the organization under the bus on CNN every night.
The legacy isn't about Favre. His legacy pretty much cannot be tarnished IMO.

It wasn't tarnished for Fran Tarkenton, Joe Montana, Emmitt Smith, Joe Namath, and on and on.

Ten years from now, all people will remember is that the Packers released or traded Brett Favre, and whomever did it will be villified.

Did Montana, Emmitt, Tarkenton, or Namath make an appearance on prime time CNN throwing their team under the bus?

Post Reply