Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
Post Reply
Online
User avatar
mikechamp
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11775
Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
Location: Southwestern Illinois

Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Post by mikechamp »

These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on August 17.

A decent amount of questions in this one, but only 1 bonus question about international signing strategy. Enjoy the read!!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/08/ ... at-69.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Tell me why I shouldn’t be completely disheartened by the Reds' performance this weekend. Should’ve swept the Brewers, instead looked like they never played baseball before.

Mark Polishuk
Winning one game against the hottest team in baseball is no mean feat. I think the Reds just caught the wrong team at the wrong time, hence the series loss.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you think Nolan Schanuel has a future ceiling of a Mark Grace-like career?

Mark Polishuk
I’m going to say no, not out of disrespect to Schanuel but more out of respect to Grace’s career. Grace was a terrific player for a long time, and it would be a huge success for Schanuel and the Angels if he can get even in the ballpark of a Grace-esque career.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you think the Reds pass the Mets and make the WC?

Mark Polishuk

The two teams have a three-game series in Cincinnati in September and looms large. The Reds are up 2-1 so far this season for tiebreaker purposes.

I think the Reds haven’t been fully able to capitalize on the Mets’ slide to this point, yet they have more momentum than New York at this point. On paper, the Mets should be able to get it together, but the chalk hasn’t amounted to anything for them over the last several weeks. Frankly, I wouldn’t even count out teams like the Cardinals, Giants, or D’Backs from making a late run just yet.

Also, every Mets fan has undoubtedly noticed that the Braves have quietly been red-hot over the last week.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Chances that the Brewers trade Peralta this off-season?

Mark Polishuk
I wouldn’t be entirely shocked since that’s just how the Brewers roll. But, Peralta at $8MM is a such a huge bargain that it carries particular value to a Brewers team working within a limited budget. As we saw with Adames, the Brewers are willing to let a talented player just reach free agency, and I suspect this might be the case here with Peralta.

Milwaukee’s pitching depth perhaps adds more fuel to the idea that Peralta could be dealt, but there’s a difference between depth and the certainty that Peralta offers as a surefire frontline guy.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
When will Bubba finally be promoted?

Mark Polishuk
Any day now. Especially with Heaney being moved to the bullpen.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are you worried (like myself) that the Cubs won’t even make the playoffs this year. They sure have looked terrible lately!!

Mark Polishuk
The Cubs still have a healthy lead on the rest of the wild card field. Despite their struggles, I think Milwaukee almost going unbeaten for like a month made Chicago’s struggles (which are real, don’t get me wrong) look a bit worse than they actually are.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Will the Braves trade Profar for salary relief and go after Tucker?

Mark Polishuk
What team would want to take on Profar’s contract, and before you say “the Padres,” remember that they have payroll limitations of their own. Signing Tucker to a mega-deal would be out of character for the Braves, and seemingly unlikely for a team that made a point of getting under the tax line last winter.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
With Stearns in NY, who is the main brain behind the Brewers success?

Mark Polishuk
This kind of consistent year-after-year succeeds needs a lot of people to keep the wheels turning rather than just one singular executive.

Obviously the Mets made a point of recruiting Stearns and the Cubs hired Counsell away, but it’s interesting that you haven’t really seen the kind of coaching/front office hiring exodus from Milwaukee that you’ve seen with other teams making a point to hire people away from the Rays, Guardians, Dodgers, etc.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What is a better strategy in the intl signing period: sign one top prospect using most of your pool or sign a few second tier guys and spread the risk? Should you alternate the two strategies?

Mark Polishuk
It’s hard to say since the international market is such a crapshoot. When dealing with prospects at such a young age, it’s so hard to view a kid as such a “sure thing” that it’s worth committing most of your pool towards a signing. We’ve seen plenty of highly-touted int’l signings over the years fizzle out in the minors, let alone in the big leagues.
-----------------------------------------------------------------

Post Reply