The issues with his demeanor and such existed long before his injury. He's carried that baggage for years. It wasn't contrived today just to "misdirect".Transmogrified Tiger wrote:That people try not to be armchair psychologists based on his sideline demeanor or how he talks to media. If you want to say Jay Cutler isn't all that good, I don't particularly disagree(or care, really). But the fact is that most of the Cutler backlash of the last 24 hours has been based on his sideline demeanor after he got hurt, and the segue to "Cutler isn't all that good" is just a misdirect after their notions of Cutler needing to play through his injury were shown to be hogwash.Richie Allen wrote:What are those of you defending Cutler arguing exactly? Does his injury free him from criticism of his feeble first half? Or any criticism of any kind?
NFL 2010 Conference Championships
-
Socnorb11
- The Last Word
- Posts: 21913
- Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am
Re: NFL 2010 Conference Championships
- Richie Allen
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 7458
- Joined: December 22 06, 1:06 am
Re: NFL 2010 Conference Championships
No. You accused me of not knowing anything about quarterbacks when I questioned the consensus opinion on Cutler's potential.thrill wrote:I'm not defending him. I'm pointing out unfair or inaccurate criticism.Richie Allen wrote:What are those of you defending Cutler arguing exactly? Does his injury free him from criticism of his feeble first half? Or any criticism of any kind?
- Richie Allen
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 7458
- Joined: December 22 06, 1:06 am
Re: NFL 2010 Conference Championships
No. Fans of the team of the player in question are never correct. Only the third party devil's advocates know the truth.Socnorb11 wrote:The issues with his demeanor and such existed long before his injury. He's carried that baggage for years. It wasn't contrived today just to "misdirect".Transmogrified Tiger wrote:That people try not to be armchair psychologists based on his sideline demeanor or how he talks to media. If you want to say Jay Cutler isn't all that good, I don't particularly disagree(or care, really). But the fact is that most of the Cutler backlash of the last 24 hours has been based on his sideline demeanor after he got hurt, and the segue to "Cutler isn't all that good" is just a misdirect after their notions of Cutler needing to play through his injury were shown to be hogwash.Richie Allen wrote:What are those of you defending Cutler arguing exactly? Does his injury free him from criticism of his feeble first half? Or any criticism of any kind?
- Transmogrified Tiger
- Puppy Murderer
- Posts: 9323
- Joined: April 25 06, 6:07 pm
- Location: Across the River
Re: NFL 2010 Conference Championships
Okay?Socnorb11 wrote:The issues with his demeanor and such existed long before his injury. He's carried that baggage for years. It wasn't contrived today just to "misdirect".Transmogrified Tiger wrote:That people try not to be armchair psychologists based on his sideline demeanor or how he talks to media. If you want to say Jay Cutler isn't all that good, I don't particularly disagree(or care, really). But the fact is that most of the Cutler backlash of the last 24 hours has been based on his sideline demeanor after he got hurt, and the segue to "Cutler isn't all that good" is just a misdirect after their notions of Cutler needing to play through his injury were shown to be hogwash.Richie Allen wrote:What are those of you defending Cutler arguing exactly? Does his injury free him from criticism of his feeble first half? Or any criticism of any kind?
This isn't hard to follow. Cutler isn't super happy fun times with media his whole career. Cutler gets hurt and stands on the sideline. Media, because they don't like Cutler for not being super happy fun times with them, jumps to the "he's faking it/he's not tough" conclusion. Info comes out that suggesting that Cutler play through his injury would be crazy. Media moves on to "he doesn't care" or "he isn't all that good".
- thrill
- bronoun enthusiast
- Posts: 30539
- Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
- Location: barely online
Re: NFL 2010 Conference Championships
Yeah, your criticism was inaccurate. You're still off your rocker if you understand my premise and disagree that he has some of the best physical tools at the position in the league.Richie Allen wrote:No. You accused me of not knowing anything about quarterbacks when I questioned the consensus opinion on Cutler's potential.thrill wrote:I'm not defending him. I'm pointing out unfair or inaccurate criticism.Richie Allen wrote:What are those of you defending Cutler arguing exactly? Does his injury free him from criticism of his feeble first half? Or any criticism of any kind?
-
Socnorb11
- The Last Word
- Posts: 21913
- Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am
Re: NFL 2010 Conference Championships
You're creating a separation that doesn't exist. It's all tied together. His demeaner on the sideline is a large part of the reason the media assumed he had "quit". He certainly looked like he had checked out mentally.Transmogrified Tiger wrote:Okay?Socnorb11 wrote:The issues with his demeanor and such existed long before his injury. He's carried that baggage for years. It wasn't contrived today just to "misdirect".Transmogrified Tiger wrote:That people try not to be armchair psychologists based on his sideline demeanor or how he talks to media. If you want to say Jay Cutler isn't all that good, I don't particularly disagree(or care, really). But the fact is that most of the Cutler backlash of the last 24 hours has been based on his sideline demeanor after he got hurt, and the segue to "Cutler isn't all that good" is just a misdirect after their notions of Cutler needing to play through his injury were shown to be hogwash.Richie Allen wrote:What are those of you defending Cutler arguing exactly? Does his injury free him from criticism of his feeble first half? Or any criticism of any kind?
This isn't hard to follow. Cutler isn't super happy fun times with media his whole career. Cutler gets hurt and stands on the sideline. Media, because they don't like Cutler for not being super happy fun times with them, jumps to the "he's faking it/he's not tough" conclusion. Info comes out that suggesting that Cutler play through his injury would be crazy. Media moves on to "he doesn't care" or "he isn't all that good".
I don't know that the media has attacked his toughness yesterday and today as much as his peers (other players) have.
Nobody really likes him, so they're not going to give him the benfit of the doubt (for better or worse). I think we can all agree on that.
-
Socnorb11
- The Last Word
- Posts: 21913
- Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am
Re: NFL 2010 Conference Championships
I think Richie's point is that, outside of his cannon arm and body stature, there's not much evidence of elite physical tools. I don't think a person would be "off their rocker" to come to that conclusion, based on 5 years of watching him play.thrill wrote:Yeah, your criticism was inaccurate. You're still off your rocker if you understand my premise and disagree that he has some of the best physical tools at the position in the league.Richie Allen wrote:No. You accused me of not knowing anything about quarterbacks when I questioned the consensus opinion on Cutler's potential.thrill wrote:I'm not defending him. I'm pointing out unfair or inaccurate criticism.Richie Allen wrote:What are those of you defending Cutler arguing exactly? Does his injury free him from criticism of his feeble first half? Or any criticism of any kind?
- thrill
- bronoun enthusiast
- Posts: 30539
- Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
- Location: barely online
Re: NFL 2010 Conference Championships
I agree with this and would be concerned if I thought Jay gave a [expletive]. He clearly doesn't, so I'm assuming it won't affect his play moving forward.Socnorb11 wrote:Nobody really likes him, so they're not going to give him the benfit of the doubt (for better or worse). I think we can all agree on that.
This is the kind of thing I take exception to. Why is this an acceptable assumption? You don't know him. You don't know how to read him. Just because someone has a dumb, blank look on their face doesn't bely their actual mind set.Socnorb11 wrote: He certainly looked like he had checked out mentally.
- thrill
- bronoun enthusiast
- Posts: 30539
- Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
- Location: barely online
Re: NFL 2010 Conference Championships
He's one of the best scrambling and running quarterback in the league.Socnorb11 wrote:I think Richie's point is that, outside of his cannon arm and body stature, there's not much evidence of elite physical tools. I don't think a person would be "off their rocker" to come to that conclusion, based on 5 years of watching him play.thrill wrote:Yeah, your criticism was inaccurate. You're still off your rocker if you understand my premise and disagree that he has some of the best physical tools at the position in the league.Richie Allen wrote:No. You accused me of not knowing anything about quarterbacks when I questioned the consensus opinion on Cutler's potential.thrill wrote:I'm not defending him. I'm pointing out unfair or inaccurate criticism.Richie Allen wrote:What are those of you defending Cutler arguing exactly? Does his injury free him from criticism of his feeble first half? Or any criticism of any kind?
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: NFL 2010 Conference Championships
The firestorm of tweets during and after the game did not come from the media, ftr.Transmogrified Tiger wrote:Okay?Socnorb11 wrote:The issues with his demeanor and such existed long before his injury. He's carried that baggage for years. It wasn't contrived today just to "misdirect".Transmogrified Tiger wrote:That people try not to be armchair psychologists based on his sideline demeanor or how he talks to media. If you want to say Jay Cutler isn't all that good, I don't particularly disagree(or care, really). But the fact is that most of the Cutler backlash of the last 24 hours has been based on his sideline demeanor after he got hurt, and the segue to "Cutler isn't all that good" is just a misdirect after their notions of Cutler needing to play through his injury were shown to be hogwash.Richie Allen wrote:What are those of you defending Cutler arguing exactly? Does his injury free him from criticism of his feeble first half? Or any criticism of any kind?
This isn't hard to follow. Cutler isn't super happy fun times with media his whole career. Cutler gets hurt and stands on the sideline. Media, because they don't like Cutler for not being super happy fun times with them, jumps to the "he's faking it/he's not tough" conclusion. Info comes out that suggesting that Cutler play through his injury would be crazy. Media moves on to "he doesn't care" or "he isn't all that good".

